Author name: Eddy Hirono

[Preview] What a Difference a Result Makes (Young Lions v Sailors)

Prior to the Tampines game, the Sailors were spoken about by most people as shoo-ins for the title, with Tampines and Geylang perhaps able to put up tough fights, but ultimately falling short as the Sailors machine kicks into gear with better depth at its disposal, and overall just better quality. One humiliating result later, suddenly the Sailors are a club in crisis, there are calls for Rankovic to be sacked, and everything is called into question. Such is the nature of sports nowadays – it is a results industry. When you lose 5-0 to a title rival to record your club’s biggest-ever margin of defeat, and fail to force the opposing goalkeeper into making a save, the negative noise really builds. Sailors fans start lashing out at individuals, such as Zharfan (who made a horrendous error for the 2nd goal, but was otherwise blameless for the rest of the goals), such as Hariss (someone who is relied upon coach after coach, but yet finds himself having to prove his worth over and over again) – but forget that it was a team failure. Who on that pitch actually came off with any credit? Tampines fans by and large are fine – but you will see a few crawling out of the gutter now and again. You see them on LCS’s IG posts, on SFT’s various social media posts. Gloating and laughing. Money can’t buy history, they say. I say to them I wish money could buy manners, because obviously they lack the class and grace to behave in a befitting manner. Don’t be a sore loser, but don’t be an ungracious winner as well. As much as we hate the negative noise, I am sure the players hate it too. They probably hate it more. A win tonight will not kill all the negative noise. We could win 22-0 with each member of the squad getting a goal at least, and get 98% possession, and people will say “Ah it’s just Young Lions” – but fail to win, and you can be sure the negative noise will reach 400 decibels. So are we gonna win? Let’s dive right into the preview. More Fighting Spirit Whatever happens tonight, the Sailors fans will want to see more fighting spirit. Against Tampines, while noone said it aloud, we were all waiting for something to spark the fans into life. Yes, the Crew and some members of the crowd were chanting – but we needed something to unite everyone. A moment of controversy, a blood-and-thunder tackle – just something for the fans to hold on to, to believe that the team out there is fighting for us. When Shah Shahiran, Yasir Hanapi and Irfan Najeeb are passing circles around you when the score is 5-0, I think the fans wouldn’t have minded if one of our players went ahead and barged a Tampines player to the floor. Yellow card? No worries. At least show you are not a training cone. It was interesting that in a post-match interview, Ranko said one of the positives was that noone got a red card. I find it interesting because that’s not a normal comment a coach makes, but also because it reveals that Ranko thought some of our players might be so frustrated that they take it out on the Tampines players. I think there’s a middle ground – you don’t have to go in and try to maim someone and get a red card, but you can absolutely be a bit more physical to show you are not ready to be messed around with, Zlatkovic did it to Nathan Mao last year, and even in last weekend’s game, Boris’s dirty challenge was meant to do exactly that – to intimidate, to distract, to assert dominance. Against the Young Lions, there may be times when the chips are down – and when that happens, I hope to see a more fighting response this time. Let’s show people that Sailors are not just about quality players, it is also about players who fight for the badge, and are willing to eliminate any obstacles in our way. Young Lions a Threat from Set Pieces With a total of 5 goals from set pieces, Young Lions are joint-top of this stat with Balestier Khalsa. However, given that Balestier Khalsa also score many more goals, a greater percentage of Young Lions goals comes from set pieces – a whopping 38%. Kaisei Ogawa is usually the architect of this success, and has 4 assists under his belt this season. Set pieces is something Joseph spoke passionately about in the aftermath of the 5-0 defeat to Tampines. I think while set-piece goals are inevitable and every team does concede them, it is the manner which really got Joseph annoyed. Irfan Najeeb was unchallenged as he headed the ball in from Faris’s corner. That came minutes after Boris Kopitovic was also unmarked with yards of space to fire home from Glenn Kweh’s cutback. Our marking will definitely have to be better if we are to get a clean sheet tonight – the Young Lions clearly work on their setpieces. Enomoto the Dangerman with Farhan Zulkifli the Wildcard Enomoto is their top-scorer with 6 goals. In the previous preview, I marked him out as someone who came with a reputation for being good in the air (in aerial duels). He has since proven to be quite useful there, especially in providing the Young Lions with a long-ball option should they need it. He has also scored once with his head this season. I like his movement a lot, and he is a major reason why Young Lions are looking competitive in all the matches they have played in this year. The other one to look out for is of course, the livewire Farhan Zulkifli. He hasn’t completed the full 90 a lot this season, and on a few occasions started from the bench. Not sure why that would be considering that I think

[Preview] What a Difference a Result Makes (Young Lions v Sailors) Read More »

[Tactical Analysis] Smashed Into Smithereens (Sailors 0 BG Tampines 5)

The following tactical analysis is from Zach Wu, who’s not a Sailors fan, but we just thought it would be good for someone without rose-tinted glasses to analyse the tactics of our games. We hope to make this a regular column so that we can better appreciate what is going on in our games from a tactical perspective. This was an early title decider and a clash of two giants of Singapore football. And the game did not disappoint. [Editor’s note: There you go, something only a non-Sailors fan could say] The 2 teams lined up as such off the ball with LCS opting for a conservative approach with a back 5 while Tampines were in their usual shape. Tampines’s Box Diamond Midfield This is where it gets interesting. Last season, Tampines played a box midfield. Check out last season’s article detailing this. Instead of having a box midfield, this year, the midfield has tilted to form a diamond midfield instead. This results in a single #10 and 2 shuttlers (Shah and Kyoga here) to support the base of the diamond (Zlatkovic who has stepped up from the defence). This worked well against LCS for a couple of reasons. First, there is an obvious 7 vs 5 advantage (in the image above) for Tampines whereby it made it almost impossible for LCS to press them. Second, instead of LCS’s midfield pivot marking the two #10s of the box midfield, the LCS midfield pivot was forced into stepping up onto the 2 shuttlers (Shah and Kyoga), leaving Kunori free between the lines if no one from the LCS stepped up.  Example #1 Here, Kyoga has dropped wide here(orange) to receive while Hariss (purple) has followed him out. With Hariss out of position and with 5 vs 6 situation here, this then leads to Zlatkovic being able to receive the ball in between the lines and facing forward (pink) with the LCS press broken- an ideal situation for Tampines. Tampines was hence able to find a free man between the lines. Example #2 Here, Hariss closes down Milos aggressively. Milos (black) then plays it out to Amirul Adli who then clips it to Shah Shahiran (pink) in the centre of the pitch. Again, Tampines have found the free man between the lines. LCS’s Approach LCS’s game plan was peculiar. While understandably weakened by the loss of Bart and Song (only fit enough to be a sub), they used 2 wingers in in the #10 roles, Shawal and Maxime for their 3-2-4-1 shape. They are players used to other roles and in my opinion not the most suited for this. Both players are renowned for their ability in the final third as compared to their trickery between the lines. Asking them to receive the ball in the middle and look to progress play might have been a little beyond them Possibly, they could have used Hami as a #10 given his quick feet in tight spaces. This definitely harmed LCS on the ball. On the ball, there was little central progression- the ball was rarely played through the centre by either the centre midfielders or the #10. This is pretty ironic as the point of LCS’s box midfield was to achieve numerical superiority in the centre and hence make it easy to progress the ball centrally. The ball went long most of the time. When the ball went wide, it was a big problem when the ball carrier (black) was unsupported. While a #10 has made a run in behind to threaten the defensive line, there was little support to expose the vacant centre (red). This should have been the job of the far sided #10 or a centre midfielder. In all, LCS were poor on the ball. Either You’re Pregnant or Not “A little bit of pressing is like a little bit of pregnant. Either you are pregnant or not? Either you want to play pressing or not.” Ralf Ragnick once said this when talking about pressing. I fully concur. Teams who press should either go for an all out aggressive press or none at all. Everything in between is futile. Unfortunately, LCS chose to be everything in between. LCS’s press was poor for a couple of reasons. Firstly, the press was uncoordinated and uncompact. Here, Thy and Lestienne are trying to engage in a press. Unfortunately the rest of the team are too far from them, making this press uncompact. The second line of pressure (rest of the team) is too far from the initial line of the press (Thy + Lestienne). This allows Irfan Najeeb to receive between the lines and take down the ball even with a bounce. Secondly, the press lacked numbers. In the above two images, this is a goal kick and Thy is curving his run to press Yamashita (first image). However because LCS have not pressed in sufficient numbers, Anu (pink) is left with 2 men to cover. This situation is illustrated here. The LCS back 5 is pinned by 3 Tampines players. This means that there are too many players at the back and hence Tampines will have an overload elsewhere. The crucial area is in the centre of the pitch (black box) where Tampines have a clear 3 vs 2 situation. Anu is unable to mark 2 players, which means even if he marks one, the other midfielder would be free to face forward and advance play. LCS should perhaps have pushed a player from the backline onto Kunori which would then allow Hariss to jump onto the other free Tampines centre midfielder. This allows LCS to mark Tampines man for man 3 vs 3 in the centre while still maintaining an overload of 4 vs 3 at the back. Lastly, the timing of the press was often poor. It felt like LCS were often just running at the Tampines defenders without waiting for a pressing trigger. Teams use a press trigger often to give them a signal to start pressing (such

[Tactical Analysis] Smashed Into Smithereens (Sailors 0 BG Tampines 5) Read More »

[Preview] Sailors v Tampines Rovers (Super Similar Sides)

Our Sailors take on Tampines in a top-of-the-table battle between two clubs that have had very very similar starts to the season. We’re both on the same number of points, have scored the same number of goals, and have the best and second-best defensive records in the league. Truly neck and neck stuff out there. Have you ever wondered why when two teams are close, they are described as being “neck and neck“? I wondered if it had its origins in athletics, where two runners would be close to each other – but that would be strange, why would their necks be near each other? So I did some digging, and it turns out that the phrase has its origins in horse racing, where two horses in competition give off the appearance that their necks are side by side. Ok TIL. Let’s gallop right into the preview. The Two Best Defences in the League That the Sailors and Tampines have such good defensive records is not by chance or sheer dumb luck. If you wonder whether it’s both sides’ respective keepers bailing them out, it’s not that either. Both teams simply concede very few shots to begin with. The Sailors (9.9) and Tampines (9.6) are the only two teams to concede an average number of shots lesser than 10 every game. For context, the next closest is Hougang with 12.0 shots per game conceded, and then Geylang with 13.1 shots conceded per game. Some of it is down to the quality of the defenders themselves. Milos Zlatkovic and Shuya Yamashita are amongst the most solid centrebacks in the league, while I don’t think anyone can disagree with the contention that Bailey Wright and Toni Datkovic is the meanest central defensive pairing in the league this season. However, some of it is also due to how “boring” both teams are. I say this with a lot of love for our Sailors of course, and with some admiration for our rivals in black and yellow. Both teams are the best in the league at controlling games. Part of this is due to the individual quality up front. When you have top-quality attackers, you do not need to throw too many men forward to create numerical overlaps. Take a look at LCS’s fullbacks for example. Lionel Tan tucks in to form a back three when he starts at right-back, while Obren Kljajic is given more licence to roam down the left. However, you seldom see Obren pop into the box to create chances or even go all the way to the byline. Part of that may be down to him shifting the primary responsibility of creating to his more esteemed teammates like Bart, Shawal and Maxime, but part of it also is that he doesn’t make penetrative runs all the time – he picks and chooses his moments. You compare that with Geylang, where routinely, you will see players like Shakir Hamzah, Naqiuddin Eunos given free rein down the left and right flanks – which undoubtedly leaves gaps behind when they get hit on the counter. While I would also like our Sailors to be more attacking – I realise how far our defence has come. There was a time (exactly one year ago), where I was bemoaning this stat. Being top of the table for most stats is good. Zharfan may take some pride in being the keeper with the most saves in July last year, but it means that the rest of the team is not doing a great job protecting the keeper. Just look last year at where Syazwan Buhari (41 saves) and Hassan Sunny (31 saves) are. Related point – Onana had the most saves of all goalkeepers in the English Premier League last season too. All that being said, I guess my point is this – we are conservative and it is paying off in terms of results. We are unbeaten, and have been unbeaten in our last 12 matches. Tampines are too, and have their own unbeaten run to protect. Their Dangermen No prizes for guessing who their two dangermen are. Seia Kunori has made a great start to life at Rovers, while Boris Kopitovic keeps up his impressive penalty-scoring record. Congratulations to Boris for scoring goals no. 100 and 101 for the Rovers over the weekend. I am kinda glad he achieved it against DPMM so we don’t have to see it happen against us. I am also reliably informed that out of the 101 goals he has scored for them, 98 were from the penalty spot, while the remaining 3 goals were tap-ins from 2 yards out. I kid, I kid. It’s a great achievement and we’d do well to shackle him properly. This season, he has scored 8 goals, and at least 1 in each of his 7 appearances. All 8 goals have been scored in the penalty area, showing his prowess in the area. 3 of his 8 goals have come via the penalty spot. He has also picked up 2 assists to boot. 10 goal contributions in 7 games – that is elite territory. I mean, Maxime has 13 in 7 games, but Maxime is far and away the best player in the league. Inside the box, if we give Boris a sniff, we’re screwed. Then we move on to Seia Kunori. Seia is a more well-rounded threat than Boris – and is also one who doesn’t really stick to a certain position. This season, we’ve seen him pop up wide left, wide right, behind the striker, in the striker position. He will be hard to keep tabs on because of his constant movement, and his ability to use both feet. Of his 5 goals scored this season, 3 have come via his left foot, while 2 have come via his right. What is also quite worrying for us is that if we retreat into our box to defend, he has the ability to hurt us from range as well. 3

[Preview] Sailors v Tampines Rovers (Super Similar Sides) Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Lack of Rhythm Worrying, but Three Points Welcome (Balestier Khalsa 2 Sailors 4)

Was it a vintage Sailors performance? No. Do I care? Yes, a little. Is it important that we head into Thursday’s top-of-the-table clash with Tampines Rovers at least level on points? Hell yeah definitely. This late result against Balestier Khalsa came right after a laboured performance against Tanjong Pagar, which also came right after a laboured performance against Geylang International. I think we should be a little worried – let’s talk about some of the observations from the game. Class from Kodai Before we talk about the not-so-good stuff, let’s get the good stuff out of the way. We spoke about Kodai’s return, we wondered whether he might get on the scoresheet, and also whether he might celebrate wildly against us. Well, he did celebrate when the Ismail Sassi decided he was prime Thierry Henry and scored a superb curled equaliser past Zharfan, but it was nothing disrespectful. Where his class really shone through was somewhere in the 55th minute of the game (watch from 55:12), when Hami Syahin cynically pulled Riku Fukashiro back on the counter-attack and deservedly got a yellow card. What followed next was Riku swung an elbow at Hami (and missed), and then gave him a shove too. Quite how Riku didn’t at least see a yellow card for this, I will never know – but the refereeing for this game was quite strange. Importantly though, with tensions rising, we then saw Kodai hug Hami and bring him away from his irate teammate. Irate teammate – unnecessary rhyme in the middle of the article? Check. It was an action that immediately helped to defuse the tension. If that hadn’t happened, I am not sure we’d have seen both Riku and Hami remaining on the field. He recognised he was one of the few players who could have played peacemaker there given his history with the Sailors, and used it to prevent further drama. Class. In a post-match post on Instagram, he also expressed thanks to the Sailors fans for chanting his name at the final whistle when he came over to shake hands with the Sailors staff. Those at the stadium would also have seen him bow towards us in the stands. As supporters, it’s little gestures like these that really provide the feel-good factor from games. Some members of the Crew had always dropped in to check on him during his lengthy injury absence, made gifts for him, etc, so it feels nice when the good feelings are acknowledged. The Penalty Call at the End Riku Fukashiro seemed to be at the centre of everything good that Balestier did, and with the score at 4-2 in the 8th minute of added-on time, it looked like Balestier was gonna get a penalty when Haiqal Pashia’s high tackle seemed to connect with Riku in the box. See it for yourself here. You can also hear the loud calls from the Sailors fans politely urging Riku Fukashiro to refrain from speaking any further. To me, this is a tough one, but I can imagine if it happened at the other end, I would think it’s a penalty. Going by that test – I think the ref got this wrong. Haiqal Pashia went in for the tackle, didn’t touch the ball, and contacted Riku a little. How much exactly? To be honest it’s not easy to tell with the camera angles, but I think given the height of the tackle, I would have given it. It capped a frustrating night for Riku. Besides the incident referred to above where Kodai played peacemaker, Riku also received a ridiculous yellow card for a nothing tackle on Shawal Anuar a few minutes earlier. While Balestier can feel hard done by, and may have had a penalty, I think it wouldn’t have made a difference because we were already well into added-on time beyond the 5 allocated minutes, and even if they had scored the penalty, we would have emerged winners. The Curious Case of Lenny Thy In a post-match interview with some fans, I managed to speak with Mike, who is interestingly Lennart Thy’s neighbour. I asked him about the chance that Lennart missed, and whether he was a little worried about his form. He said that supporters should be more patient, given that Lenny has shown he can do it at a higher level (the Eredivisie), and also because he has barely played a few games for us in a distinctly different environment and climate compared to the Netherlands. His family has also just joined him not long ago, so a little adaptation time shouldn’t be too much to ask for. I agree – and want to add another factor into the mix. I’ve touched on this before but Lenny has come off a full season playing as the main striker for PEC Zwolle, into an LCS team without much rest at all. His season ended in May and he was already playing for us in June. I think we can be more patient – some fans are already calling him a “flop”, and asking for Richi to come back. Yet, I think we can be more patient while acknowledging that it was a bad miss by him on Saturday. From here – you have to score, or force a world-class save from the keeper. Yes, the ball was bouncing, but we expect better from our marquee striker. We hope he’ll be burying these soon! But yet, why is this section entitled the Curious Case of Lenny Thy? It’s because I really want us to form our own views on whether we feel Lenny has been doing alright. In 5 games, he has scored 1 goal, and got 3 assists. Judging him based on that, we’d quite justifiably feel there is much room for improvement. However, I somehow get the feeling that he’s playing in a team that is still not used to him, or in certain cases, not passing to him. Should Haiqal square this to him, it’s 5-2,

[Post-Match Thoughts] Lack of Rhythm Worrying, but Three Points Welcome (Balestier Khalsa 2 Sailors 4) Read More »

[Preview] Balestier Khalsa v Sailors (Will Balestier Stick to their Guns?)

This was earmarked as one of the tougher games we would have to face this season, and it is certainly shaping up that way. Although Balestier Khalsa come into this game 5 points behind us with a vastly inferior goal difference, they have actually performed well in every game they’ve played this season. And oh, about that inferior goal difference in relation to us? They just have not played Albirex yet. I know this is a Balestier preview, but you gotta have some sympathy for Albirex. The league table shows them scoring the fewest goals in the league, and conceding the most. They have now choked two leads despite having a one-man advantage for practically the whole second half. That these two games were against Young Lions and Tanjong Pagar will only make them feel worse because these are the two teams that they will feel they should be able to compete with – whether it be a transition year or not. But enough of that digression – Balestier is scary, and let’s dive right into the preview to figure out why. Kodai Tanaka is a Goal Machine I mean – you didn’t need me to tell you this. But I’ll tell you anyway. 2nd in the league top-scorer charts, Kodai has 8 goals in 6 matches. That’s more than a goal a game. Surely he can’t keep this up, I hear you say. Oh yes, he can. In the season before he joined us, Kodai notched 39 goals in 32 games for Albirex. He also scored in every match in the Singapore Cup that he played in that year for them – and when he got injured prior to the 2nd leg of the semi-final against Hougang, Albirex lost. Hmm. So more than a goal a game is definitely not uncharted territory for Kodai. Unlike Tomoyuki Doi, who shoots from anywhere, Kodai’s goals all come from inside the penalty area, and usually in very good positions too. This is indicative of a striker who has the knack of being in the right place at the right time. The stats paint the same picture – his 8 goals come from a cumulative xG of 7.28, suggesting that he is scoring just about the same number of goals from the positions he’s getting into. (For reference, Tomoyuki Doi’s 12 goals have come from a cumulative xG of 6.88, which is insane) Aside from just being a top-scorer, Kodai will have added motivation to prove to the Sailors management that they should have kept him. His time with us was truly unfortunate. The fans loved him, he scored 3 goals in his first 3 appearances, and then an untimely and sickening injury happened to him at the Jurong East Stadium. As his knee buckled under him, the fans feared the worst – and their worst fears came through. ACL injury, out for practically the whole season. He will be chomping at the bit to try and score against us I’m sure. In pre-season, in a match I didn’t attend, apparently he scored against us and started cupping his ears in the direction of the Sailors end. Some bad blood perhaps? Or just a cheeky celebration? I don’t wanna find out tonight haha. Kodai was missing last game with an injury, but I am pretty sure he will be sacrificing all manner of animals to the injury gods to make sure he can play this game. Bailey and Toni will have a tough task on their hands trying to keep Kodai quiet. But if they could keep Tomoyuki Doi quiet, then maybe they can do the same for Kodai too. Fingers crossed! Riku Fukashiro – the Livewire Riku is the 3rd-highest assists-maker in the league this season. If I could have picked one player from last season’s Albirex team to bring over to the Sailors, it would have been this guy. He is just so entertaining to watch. Just this season, he’s tried a rainbow flick in a game, and while I don’t have the stats, I am willing to bet that he is among the top dribblers in the league. Last season, Riku had very limited playing time, but yet managed impressive numbers. He had 9 goals and 8 assists from 29 appearances. While those are already commendable numbers, when you take into account that he only started 7 times out of 29, those contribution numbers start to look alot more impressive. This season, Riku has been in a rich vein of form. Always tormenting defenders in and around the box, he has 2 goals and 5 assists already. Add to that one penalty won, and he’s directly been responsible for 8 out of Balestier’s 19 goals. He’s definitely a key player and one to watch for our defenders. I wonder if he might cause Lionel or Chris some trouble down the flanks if he drifts out there. Unlike the Geylang game where Geylang didn’t seem really intent on finding anyone except Doi with the ball, I think the attacking threat will be a lot more varied in tonight’s game. Will Balestier Attack? This is a screengrab right before Ismail Sassi on the far side slips Fukashiro (no. 9) in behind the defence for him to cross to Amiruldin Asraf (no. 19) waiting for the cutback on the penalty spot. I chose this picture to illustrate that Balestier is a very creative team that doesn’t rely on just lumping the ball into the box at every opportunity. Look at Ismail with the ball at his right foot. I dare say that 8 out of 10 players, would see Madhu and Amer Hakeem in the box, and decide to just cross it in. It’s not even an irrational choice – the aerial presence of Madhu and Amer will cause problems. However, they’ve shown on more than one occasion this season that they are a team that will make that extra pass on attack, consistent with Peter de Roo’s attacking ethos. When you

[Preview] Balestier Khalsa v Sailors (Will Balestier Stick to their Guns?) Read More »

[Preview] Sailors v Tanjong Pagar (Thrashing on the Cards?)

With the Sailors 2nd in the table (with Tampines Rovers having played one more game), and Tanjong Pagar languishing in the bottom 3, everyone is expecting the Sailors to just turn up and win. In this preview, we’ll look at Tanjong Pagar’s performances thus far, assess the need for rotation, and answer the question “Is it really gonna be that easy for our Sailors to beat Tanjong Pagar?“ Tanjong Pagar have an Awful Attack Yes. The answer to the question posed above is “Yes”. I couldn’t say Yes loud enough. For those who are of a certain vintage, imagine the “Yes” to be as resounding and as loud as Sally’s “Yes” in the restaurant in 1989 classic film When Harry Met Sally. With 6 goals in 5 games, Tanjong Pagar have the joint-worst attack along with Albirex Niigata (S). (At the time of writing, Albirex have played one more game and failed to add to their goal tally, after a disastrous 6-0 loss to Geylang.) They create very few chances because they sit back most of the time, and thus struggle to get bodies into attack. Their top-scorer is Salif Cisse, who has overcome a slow start to the season to score 2 goals in his last 2 games. He has looked quite a handful, even if his CV is quite unimpressive. In fact, by scoring 2 goals, he has already equalled his highest-ever season tally. Of course, some of those leagues, like the French 2nd tier, Bulgarian 1st tier, and the Lithuanian 1st tier, are likely to be of a higher standard than our SPL. It seems he has finally found his level in the SPL, and if they are to get anything from the game, much hope should lie on Salif Cisse’s shoulders. The other player that our Sailors will do well to try to shut down will be Shodai Nishikawa, a player more known usually for his industry than for his skill. He has 3 assists in his last 2 games. Overall though, with the lowest xG in the league, and our defence being the stingiest in the league, we should be keeping Tanjong Pagar at bay. Is Their Defence as Bad as it Seems? If you asked someone not to refer to the table and guess where Tanjong Pagar lies in terms of goals conceded, I think most would guess that they are near the bottom. However, with 14 goals conceded, they are actually near the middle of the table when it comes to number of goals conceded. Young Lions (19), Hougang (20), and Albirex (23) have worse defensive records, whiile Brunei DPMM have conceded the same number of goals (14). Teams like Geylang and Balestier have only conceded one fewer goal than Tanjong Pagar. Why then, is there this impression that Tanjong Pagar cannot defend? Upon closer inspection, one stat perhaps goes some way to explaining this. Out of the 14 goals conceded by Tanjong Pagar, 12 have been inside the penalty area, but even more shockingly, 7 have been scored from inside the 6-yard box. Half their goals! This suggests that Tanjong Pagar is laying the red carpet out for teams to slice them right open and walk their way into goal. This stat is all the more surprising when you consider that Tanjong Pagar sit so deep inside their own half for the majority of the game. Against the tricky and skilful players that the Sailors have, Tanjong Pagar might find themselves having a tough time. Bart’s Injury Brings Up Interesting Possibilities Bart limped off in the game against Geylang, and was clutching the back of his hamstring. We have no injury updates to go on, so I am gonna assume that he will be sitting this game out, because usually even the slightest of hamstring strains rules a player out for about 2 weeks. Add to that the fact that we are facing a team much weaker than us, and I truly believe there will be some common sense applied to protect a player who is so key to the way we play. Simply put, we shouldn’t have to rely on him being available to beat Tanjong Pagar. This raises some interesting possibilities because we get to put another foreigner into the starting lineup. Our foreign players selected has usually been – Maxime Lestienne, Lennart Thy, Bart Ramselaar, Toni Datkovic (any foreigner, any age) Bailey Wright (foreigner from AFC nation) Obren Kljajic (U21) Besides these players, there’s realistically only two players who can expect some gametime – Rui Pires, who cannot fit in the U21 or AFC foreigner slot and Sergio Carmona who takes up a U21 slot. It is interesting to note that Obren Kljajic is a versatile player not just in terms of on-pitch position, but also foreigner eligibility, because he can take up a U21 slot, or an AFC slot. If for some reason Bailey Wright isn’t playing, Obren could take his AFC spot, and that would allow Carmona to take the U21 slot. With Bart injured/rested, I think it might be timely for Rui Pires to make his return. He has been missing from the team because of injury, but he was featured in the Inside Training video released by the club yesterday. He has been out for some time, so I don’t expect him to start, but I think we might see him from the bench. Something to look forward to. It seems apt also to comment on a recent debate that took place – some fans (both LCS fans and rival fans) felt that LCS did not plan their transfers well, because they had more foreigners than they could play. On the contrary, I think it is fantastic planning. Having one additional first-team foreigner might mean that someone gets disgruntled, but that is something that coaches need to take care of. By having an additional foreigner of first-team quality, it offers the Sailors some security in our options. Should we unfortunately lose someone to an

[Preview] Sailors v Tanjong Pagar (Thrashing on the Cards?) Read More »

[Specials] FAS Must Do Better (A Look at the Luka Lalic Debacle)

The Football Association of Singapore have fined our Technical Director Luka Lalic S$5000 for a post which made fun of the officiating during our 7-1 win over Albirex Niigata (S). I am still very annoyed by how this whole episode was handled, so let me dive into a few areas where I think the FAS really could have done better. It Was the Correct Charge for Luka Let me start off by saying that by the letter of the law, Luka Lalic is guilty of what he was accused of. He was accused of breaching Clause 92.1 of the Singapore Premier League 2024/2025 Regulations. By the letter of the law, sure he did breach it. Luka also accepted it, and “[acknowledged] that he could have acted differently to communicate his views on these topics in a more effective manner”. He also “expressed regret for his actions”. Let’s look at the offending post in question – Thank you Deepanraj Ganesan for the screenshot. By the letter of the law – it can be said to be disparaging because it seems that Luka meant to say that the VAR team is a bunch of clowns. I think he would have got away with it if his caption was “This is a goal, with VAR. That cannot be”, or “This is a goal, with VAR. We have to do better”. Those are probably more fine, because he is just stating facts. Anyone with half an eye can see this is an offside goal. But clowns? While it’s funny and I am sure supporters called the VAR team far, far worse, club staff and players must understand that their words carry more weight than that of the average layman, and so they should rightly be held to higher standards. Ok, so it was the correct charge, but should he have been charged, and was the fine excessive? Let’s dive into that. Luka Should Not Have Been Charged – Bad Optics I put myself in the shoes of the FAS. A club official just took a shit on our referees. However, the mistake was a really really poor one. It was an offside so clear that we called it from the stands. I remember being so confident that VAR would review it and disallow it. But hey, it wasn’t disallowed. Mistakes happen. Even the great English Premier League had a very similar incident, where Luis Diaz’s goal was wrongly disallowed due to a VAR error. The opposite of what happened, but no less important. In the aftermath, Jurgen Klopp called it a crazy decision, and said that the circumstances were very unfair. Virgil van Dijk said that he was losing faith in VAR. Both were not punished for their comments. The point of punishing players and officials for disparaging remarks is to ensure that matchgoers, footballers, and all involved in football do not lose faith in the institution. However, in this case, FAS should have taken a peek at how our friends in the EPL handled it and applied common sense. Yes, by the letter of the law, you can throw the book at Luka Lalic. But should you? When your officials made a monumental error and all Luka said was [clown emoji] [clown emoji] [clown emoji]? It’s like cheating on your wife, NOT APOLOGISING, and then pointing out to her that oh by the way I know I screwed up, but you are still not allowed to rant about it on IG – didn’t we say before that what happens in our marriage stays between us? Err hello, you made the mistake first right? I would have gone with a private / public warning for Luka Lalic, and then an APOLOGY for my officials making such an error. I also feel that the timing of these two statements together is not by coincidence. If you’re wondering why I bolded and underlined those words, it’s because if you read their statement carefully, FAS did not apologise. Sorry Seems to be the Hardest Word Excuse me. Where is the apology? Where is the word “sorry”, or “apologise”? When supporters are aggrieved at a decision, when you’ve let your stakeholders down, the least you could do is apologise. We know that officials are human. The role of a referee is not an easy one. I took the refereeing course offered by FAS before and came out with a much greater appreciation for what our officials do week in week out. So let me be clear – referees can make mistakes. They are just like you and I. But unlike you and I, it seems that the organisation protects them to such a degree that it cannot apologise on their behalf. The effort it takes to craft such a media statement, artfully dodging the words “sorry”, “apologise”, “regret”, “let down”, or any word that would convey anything remotely resembling an apology is truly amazing. If only they had put such effort into their match previews. Not only are the bullet points not worthy of being stand-alone bullet points, the team news for Brunei DPMM is wrong. In the match right before this game, Farshad Noor was sent off for two yellow cards. Also, DPMM had already published on their website that their Aussie centreback Flottmann would be out for a long time with an ACL injury. At the time of publishing, Flottmann had already missed two games and the commentators had already discussed his injury. I am not even asking whoever came up with this to look up stats and love the game as much as I do. I am just asking him to watch the game and give a shit. That’s not too much to ask for, surely. Ok I digress. Back to the things FAS could have done better with this debacle. But ok la dammit, that preview didn’t come from an organisation that loves football. Ok really back this time. Luka’s Fine was Disproportionate So ok fine, you wanna set an example, you wanna

[Specials] FAS Must Do Better (A Look at the Luka Lalic Debacle) Read More »

[Preview] Geylang v Sailors – Attack v Attack

The league’s two highest-scoring teams meet – Geylang with 22 goals from 5 games, and our Sailors, with 16 goals from 4 games. Very impressive goalscoring form from both sides, but the weird fact that pops out to me is that Geylang have conceded 4 goals from the penalty spot this season. That is unusually high considering there have only been 7 penalties awarded this season. Can we draw any conclusions from that stat? Will either team lose their unbeaten start to the season thus far? Let’s dive right into the preview. Goals, goals, goals Geylang have the highest goals per game ratio in the whole league. They have scored 22 and conceded 12, which makes it a whopping 6.8 goals per game. They have certainly been a fun side to watch. Our Sailors as well, have scored 16, but I think you don’t need to have a very good memory to remember that almost half of those were directly contributed by that game against Albirex. So does this mean that this is going to be a goalfest? Well, not necessarily. It really depends on how Geylang is going to set up. Is Noor Ali likely to continue with his side’s swashbuckling ways against our Sailors? I doubt he will. Seeing Albirex get absolutely ripped apart on the counter-attack is likely to figure in his thinking a little. If you’ve watched Geylang games this season, you’ll notice that they get good numbers into the box, and they always support the attack. This is partly due to the coaching philosophy, but partly also due to the personnel Noor Ali has at his disposal. In previous seasons, Bezecourt used to be the most advanced of the midfielders, and would regularly pop up right behind the striker. However this year, due to the recruitment of Ryoya Taniguchi, and possibly also because of the injury to Huzaifah Aziz, Bezecourt has been played in a deeper position. That doesn’t mean he is holding back in midfield, he gets involved in the attack quite a bit too. You put an attack-minded player in central midfield, and then ahead of him you have attacking talents like Iqbal, Ryoya, Doi, and Naqi – it is no wonder the players always seem to be in and around the box. Their attacking instincts are well-suited for the way they want to play. However, as mentioned above, I suspect Noor Ali will rein his players in a little. Our Sailors usually leave at least two forwards up (Maxime + 1 other) when we defend, so Geylang might find it difficult to get as many players up in attack as they usually do. If they do choose to sit back a little, they will have to trust that whatever chances they can create upfront are put away by their star striker, Tomoyuki Doi. Tomoyuki Doi is a Goalscoring Machine Maradoina, van Nisteldoi, Ronaldoi, Lewandoiski. Call him what you want, but this man scores goals. He is the current top-scorer of the SPL with 9 goals. If you add in his assists as well (2), he is responsible for half of Geylang’s goals. He has also scored in every game this season. The praise doesn’t stop there. He has scored 9 goals from a total xG of just 4.61, which goes to show how clinical he is, and how he is helping turn half-chances into goals. 5 goals on his stronger right foot, 3 goals on his weaker left foot, 1 goal with his head – man’s an all-rounder. Of his 9 goals, 3 have come from outside the box, showing that he really is a striker who can do it all. Back in 2021, he was both the SPL Player of the Year and also the league top-scorer with 19 goals in a shortened season. This year, he is on course to do much better than that. He is the obvious dangerman, and if we are to keep a clean sheet, our defenders and keeper are gonna have to be on top form. Geylang’s Shaky Defence If all that talk about Tomoyuki Doi has got you feeling a little pessimistic, perhaps this section might cheer you up a little. Geylang’s record of 12 goals conceded is equal to that of Tanjong Pagar’s (albeit having played 1 game more). Let that sink in. Tanjong Pagar Utd this season feels like the kind of team that can get relegated even though there is no relegation in the SPL. And Geylang have conceded as many goals as them. Compare that with the Sailors having conceded only 3 goals thus far, and it’s a world of a difference. If you ask me, I think there are two key differences. When you see players like Shakir Hamzah getting goals and assists, it’s nice to see, but the flipside of that is that if the transitions are done well, then it leaves big holes for opponents to exploit. Let’s now talk about Geylang’s penalty-conceding record. There have been 7 penalties awarded this season – 4 is more than half the penalties awarded, and even though it’s early days, it would seem that Geylang’s defence has a propensity for panicking in the box and committing rash fouls. You couple this unique stat with another rare one, that they have given up 2-goal leads 3 times in 5 games – and it goes a long way to show that Geylang has not got their defence sorted. Last week was the clearest example, when they somehow contrived to give up a 2-goal lead to 10-man Brunei DPMM. Conclusion Looking at both sides’ form heading into this one, it would seem like a no-brainer for this to be a high-scoring affair. But I don’t know – I feel like both sides will respect each other, and it might then lead to a bit of a tense atmosphere, especially in the first half. Just a weird feeling I have. Noor Ali should be aware that if he turns this into a shoot-out,

[Preview] Geylang v Sailors – Attack v Attack Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] White Swans Experience a Black Swan Event (Sailors 7 Albirex 1)

A Black Swan Event is defined as an unpredictable event that is beyond what is normally expected from a situation and that has potentially severe consequences. Black swan events are characterised by their extreme rarity, severe impact and the widespread insistence they were obvious in hindsight. Joseph and I had predicted huge wins for the Sailors, and we were not alone. In the SailorFanTalk Telegram chat, 44 out of 44 predictions went for a Sailors win, with more than half predicting a win by 3 or more goals. If you thought that was just because of Sailors bias, this confidence in the Sailors was also found in the prediction league of The Goal Difference Telegram chat. Out of 16 predictions, all 16 went for a Sailors win, with more than half predicting a win by 3 or more goals. Basically, everyone saw this coming. Let’s dive right into my post-match thoughts. Albirex’s Goal was Offside It’s a shocking decision by the VAR. Shuhei Hoshino wasn’t just marginally offside, he was a full body-length offside. Great cross by Arshad, but that is as offside as they come. We are lucky that this didn’t really matter in the end because we still cruised to victory, but try telling Bailey Wright and the rest of his defenders that. When we interviewed him after the game, he was frustrated that the officials got this one so wrong, and he further shared that the replay was already making its rounds in the team Whatsapp groupchat. Regardless of how it ended, I hope FAS releases a public statement about this decision. I mean – they’ve done it before in the past, haven’t they? Just because it didn’t affect the outcome of the game doesn’t mean that the public doesn’t deserve an explanation for what happened. Let’s hope they do the right thing. Speaking of doing the right thing – Albirex’s social media team did exactly the wrong thing. Why on God’s green earth would you proudly put up a replay of a blatantly offside goal? Mystifying and desperate – two adjectives that I could also use to describe their form right now. Quality of the Goals In the aftermath of the game, there were some tongue-in-cheek comments on social media posts pointing out that Hassan Sunny was a specialist in conceding 7 goals. In truth though, without Hassan Sunny, this game could have been a lot worse for Albirex. Watching from the stands, you could tell that the goals were brilliant. Borne out of free-flowing moves, we exploited the space left behind by Albirex repeatedly and finished with aplomb time after time. However it is only upon watching the highlights on Youtube that you realise just how brilliant the goals were. Hassan had no chance, as almost every goal was put into the corner, or even better, the area of the net where it hits the inside of the side netting. Let’s go through the goals. Of the 7 goals, 6 were what I would call “unsaveable”. I don’t think Hassan put a foot wrong, but the quality of the shots was just too high. A few inches closer to him and he might have saved a few. Diversity of Threat At one point in the game, we were leading 6-1, and we had 6 different goalscorers. That felt really good. Unlike other teams in the league where there’s a bit of over-reliance on one or two players, the varied nature of our threats means that opponents cannot just concentrate on marking out one or two players. On a night when our top-scorer Shawal Anuar went off, we still had the firepower to put Albirex to the sword. Despite Lennart Thy perhaps not getting the ball as much as he’d like, he had a massive influence on the game because of the players around him. Let me elaborate. Lennart Thy Looks Frustrated At times in the game, Lennart looked frustrated that his teammates were not passing to him. Notably when Lennart assisted Maxime for goal no. 6 with a fantastic pass, the two players did not celebrate together. Some tension? Maybe. Should we be worried about the tension this early into his career? I don’t think so, this is natural for two reasons. Let’s zoom in on that 2nd point. History has shown us that when there are 2 or 3 top goalscorers in the team, one of them usually plays the unselfish role, creating for his teammates. Rooney and Ronaldo in Manchester United, Bergkamp and Henry in Arsenal, Firmino doing the hard work for Salah and Mane to get the goals. Maxime finished as our top-scorer last season, while I pointed out in my piece on Bart Ramselaar that he is a player who scores more than he assists. Lennart is gonna have to get used to them sometimes turning down the chance to pass to him. However, what he offers to the team is so much more than just goals. In the above screenshots you can see in the lead-up to the 5th goal, Lennart drags his defender with him by making a run to the right side of the box. That leaves Bart completely free. He then continues to make himself available to split the attention of the defenders, before Bart eventually chooses to go for the shot himself. Another example of his runs helping to create space for his teammates can be seen in the 7th goal. Hafiz Nor looks for the options in the box, and sees Bart completely free. This is because Lennart had made a run right in front of goal, and the defenders were preoccupied with defending that threat. His runs are convincing because the defenders fear his finishing threat, but also because he takes up positions where if the pass was made to him, he could still do some damage. These runs are not obvious decoy runs. In case you are still not impressed by his runs, check this out. When Lennart picks up possession here,

[Post-Match Thoughts] White Swans Experience a Black Swan Event (Sailors 7 Albirex 1) Read More »

[Preview] Sailors v Albirex – Chance to Extend Perfect Record

Games against Albirex don’t usually feel like this. For the first time in forever, we go in as overwhelming favourites. Albirex has the 2nd-worst attack in the league, scoring only 5 goals in 4 games. If you add the Community Shield to that, they have 5 goals in 5 games. Defensively? They aren’t much better there. Despite having Hassan Sunny in their ranks, they have conceded 10 goals in the league, a stat that is only better than Young Lions (14), and Hougang (15). Even Tanjong Pagar have conceded fewer goals. I said back in May before the Community Shield that the Albirex game was a chance to lay down a marker. Well, now it’s time to take that marker, unscrew the cap, and draw something funny on Albirex’s face. Not only must we beat Albirex this weekend, I think we have to convincingly demolish them to try and shake off some of the history against them, having lost two title races to them in recent seasons. Sputtering Attack It says something about Albirex’s attackers this season when they bring in an unknown Japanese striker from a US college team and he immediately doubles the goal tally of other established attackers such as Daniel Goh and Shuhei Hoshino. Daniel and Shuhei impressed last season. Daniel had 9 goals and 6 assists in all competitions, and was always a livewire down the right wing. Shuhei had 16 goals and 13 assists, and the pair of them were part of an impressive Balestier Khalsa attack that scored the 3rd-most goals in the league. It was perhaps this form that saw some rumours about our Sailors possibly signing Daniel Goh in the off-season. However, he has not been able to reach the heights of last season at all. Daniel has 1 goal and 0 assists this season, which is poor considering that he is often the focal point of the Albirex attack. At every opportunity, Albirex try to set Daniel Goh free down the right, but he has seldom been able to beat his man and put in a meaningful ball. Daniel’s only goal came in a loss against Tampines, an instinctive lob over Syazwan Buhari after a brilliant through pass from Shuhei Hoshino. That was Shuhei’s only assist of the season, and he too, has struggled to hit the form he achieved last season. With Daniel and Shuhei in poor form, our Sailors will feel confident of shutting out the Albirex attack. Brittle Defence And now we move on to the defence. I think it says a lot that if you ask people who are the standouts in this Albirex team, they will either tell you it’s Hassan Sunny, or their centreback Stevia Egbus Mikuni. The pair of them have been put under a lot of pressure, and despite their best efforts, Albirex still has the 3rd-weakest defence in the league. This is definitely not what Hassan Sunny signed up for. I mean I could end this whole article by saying that Albirex lost to 10-men Young Lions despite being in the lead. That should be enough to tell its own story of a defence that is so weak. Just look at how Enomoto scored the Young Lions’ 2nd goal last week. A routine long ball from defence, and Enomoto was 1v1 with Hassan Sunny. Simply unacceptable. But let’s take a deeper look. Of the 10 goals Albirex have conceded this season, 8 have been from open play. 8 of the goals have also been scored from inside the box. It suggests that that they are easy to play through. The eye-test also confirms that they have real problems defending transitions. Take the above for example. It’s 2-2, Albirex are defending against 10-man Young Lions, and somehow they overcommit in the near side of the box, drawn by the threat of Farhan Zulkifli after he made a promising run down the left flank. How can one man draw the attention of 4 players like that, leaving Andrew Aw the freedom of the box? Similarly here, too much attention is paid to the man with the ball, and there’s a complete lack of midfield cover to notice that there are 2 DPMM players at the top of the box with nobody marking them at all. One is outside the box, while the other is Julio Cruz, who buries this chance easily. Ho Wai Loon has over-committed and his midfield teammmates did him no favours by not chasing back in time. You will see this happening again tomorrow I think – players sucked into situations but not affecting the ball or the dribbler enough, leading to free men ready to punish Albirex. Lennart Thy There was quite a bit of criticism for Lennart Thy on his debut. When I spoke to him after the game, he seemed kinda disappointed as well – or maybe he is just a man of few words. Naumovski did well to deny him, and of course, I think he had further chances with his head and left foot that he did not take. Some people on The Final Whistle Telegram chat immediately wrote him off. Sailors fans are likely to be more patient, as we remember that Richairo Zivkovic had a slow start for us too, but then went on to become a regular goalscorer for us. In fact, something interesting to note – Richairo debuted against DPMM last year but did not manage to get a goal, but scored against Albirex in the next game. Our next game? Albirex. Aside from the chances, I was quite impressed with Lennart’s play. He gives us an option to go long from the back, as he is quite tall and strong. Twice in the game against DPMM, a long hopeful ball was played out from the back and he managed to knock it down to a teammate. This gives us greater variety in our build-up options. Shawal Anuar How is Shawal Anuar 33? His pace, his agility, his gravity-defying leaps

[Preview] Sailors v Albirex – Chance to Extend Perfect Record Read More »