Author name: Eddy Hirono

[Preview] Sailors v Jeonbuk – Artificial Pitch, Real Hope?

If it feels like a really long time since the Sailors last played, that’s because it has been 2 weeks since our Sailors were last in action, when they deservedly lost 3-0 to Jeonbuk in the Jeonju World Cup Stadium. I’ve summed up my thoughts in the post-match thoughts article, so if you haven’t read it yet, please go take a look. So do we have a better shot at picking up a point or even all three? Let’s jump straight into the preview then! Smaller Astroturf Pitch In the official club interview, Super had this to say – “It’s going to be a different game here because it is hotter here than in Korea, the field is smaller and we are playing on an artificial surface. Jeonbuk play really nice football, but we are going to make it tough for them,” So that got me checking – what exactly is the size difference? Turns out, actually it’s quite substantial. (stats taken from transfermarkt.com) Smaller Pitch Jalan Besar Stadium – 98m x 64m Jeonju World Cup Stadium – 105m x 68m In the post-match article, I talked about how Jeonbuk’s wingers exploited our defence on the wings, and I just wonder, now that the pitch is significantly smaller, whether we will be able to contain them a little better. Don’t look down on what may seem like a measly 4m difference. Especially when we are playing 5 at the back, there will be less space for each defender to cover width-wise. Length-wise, it also allows us to get from back to front that little bit quicker, and that may suit us on the counter-attack. Artificial Pitch It is no secret that foreign teams that come here absolutely hate playing on our astroturf. The ball bounces different, the surface is hard for the players, and it takes a while for teams to get used to it. Some of the greatest nights in Home United’s AFC Cup history were achieved under the lights on the bouncy astroturf pitch at Jalan Besar Stadium. If you cast your mind back a couple of months, you will remember that a technically proficient team like Bangkok United also took more than a half to get to grips with the astroturf surface. Am I clutching at straws? Maybe a bit – we still did ultimately lose to Bangkok United, and Singapore’s national team has also lost games before at Jalan Besar despite this supposed pitch advantage. But hey, something is better than nothing. Jeonbuk’s FA Cup Final Defeat Jeonbuk come into this game having led 1-0 and 2-1 against bitter rivals Pohang Steelers in the Korean FA Cup Final. However, 3 goals in the span of 17 minutes ensured that they will not finish with any domestic silverware this season. How will that affect them coming into tonight’s game? It’s anyone’s guess, really. They might be angry and want to bounce back immediately, or they might still be hurting and turn in a listless performance. Or it might be something in the middle – this is not a computer game after all where morale is measured in terms of quantifiable numbers. Let’s try to make an educated guess by looking at their form this season after suffering a loss. Considering Jeonbuk on paper should have easily been the top 2 or 3 teams in Korea this season, it is quite surprising to see that on five separate occasions, they followed up a loss with a draw/loss. I have highlighted those occasions where they did not bounce back with a win by bolding those lines. 25 Feb 2023 – lost to Ulsan, drew with Suwon Bluewings 19 Mar 2023 – Lost to Daegu, lost to Pohang Steelers 15 April 2023 – Lost to Suwon 26 April 2023 – Lost to Daejeon Hana Citizen, lost to Gangwon, draw with Seoul 29 May 2023 – Lost to Pohang Steelers 24 June 2023 – Lost to Gwangju 21 July 2023 – Lost to Pohang Steelers 19 Aug 2023 – Lost to Ulsan, draw with Daejeon Hana Citizen, draw with Jeju United, lost to Gangwon 30 Sep 2023 – Lost to Daegu, lost to Bangkok Utd Does this suggest that they do not have mental strength and cannot bounce back? No I don’t think so. I just checked to find out if there was a trend, but it doesn’t seem like there’s anything noteworthy there. I already did the work though, so I thought I’d just share! Rest Time What may be more crucial though, is the rest time that the Sailors have had compared to their Korean counterparts. Since the last time we faced Jeonbuk, they have played 3 matches in 7 days, culminating in that cup final loss to Pohang Steelers. While there has been some rotation, key midfielder Paik Seung Ho has started all 3 games, and the hope of course is that fatigue will help to take some of the sharpness off the Jeonbuk players. While following the FA Cup final on the weekend, I was secretly hoping it would drag on to extra time, and then to penalties, to prolong the game, and add some unwanted minutes into those tired legs, rendering them a weaker prospect to deal with. The obvious counter to this point is simply that Jeonbuk rested 4 key first-team players against us and still came away with a handsome victory last time they faced us – so perhaps their strength in depth will make this less of an issue for them. Must-Win Game I don’t think much more needs to be said once you look at the table. Should Jeonbuk beat us, they’ll go up to 9 points, and we’ll be stuck on 3. Assuming Bangkok United beats Kitchee, then Bangkok will be on 12 pts, Jeonbuk on 9, and even if we win our last two fixtures, Jeonbuk just needs 1 more point from their games against Bangkok United and Kitchee to ensure we do not finish in 2nd. A draw

[Preview] Sailors v Jeonbuk – Artificial Pitch, Real Hope? Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] A Different League (Jeonbuk 3 Sailors 0)

At the end of the day, the K-League is the K-League. The Singapore Premier League is the Singapore Premier League. I dared to dream the impossible dream and that dream did not materialise. But was flying all the way to Seoul, and then taking a 4h ride to Jeonju to lose 3-0 a waste of time? Not at all. Here are some of my thoughts. A “Weakened” Jeonbuk Lineup When the Jeonbuk lineup was released – a flicker of hope lit up in my heart. No Paik Seung-ho, no Boateng, no Gustavo. Park Jae-Yong leading the line. He had just come a few months ago from K League 2. Were our opponents underestimating us? Maybe we had a shot? Let me bring you back to what I said in the preview. Wish I could’ve spoken to a Korean expert before the trip so that my preview can focus on a few key individuals. I will give you a few to look out for anyway. Paik Seung Ho, Han Kyo Won, Gustavo and Boateng. – Eddy in the preview article published 1 day before the game. What a genius. I am like a reverse fortune-teller. I named 4 players to look out for and none of the 4 players started. Wow. Of all the players that could be rested because Dan Petrescu had an eye on the weekend’s clash against Pohang Steelers, he rested the 4 that I told you guys to look out for. Or if you don’t believe in fortune tellers because they are usually a crock of shit, then maybe I am a fortune teller. I can’t tell you the future but I’ll tell you what I felt when I saw the lineup though. There was a flicker of hope. I feel like such a fool right now, but I can’t lie. I remember thinking to myself – “don’t jinx the team, Eddy, don’t tell the rest of the Crew that this is a weakened Jeonbuk lineup and that we have a huge chance. They are underestimating us, and they will regret this. “ Well – that’s what being a die-hard fan does to you I think. You see the positives in any situation and you fail to see the bigger picture. Had I taken a step back and looked at the whole team, there’s still the likes of Kim Jin Su – 68 caps for the South Korea national team, at left-back. Next to him, at centreback, Hong Jeong Ho, with 42 caps. Moon at left-wing, Ahn at right-back, Jun Amano in midfield – also senior internationals (Korea, Korea, Japan). That’s a whole lot of caps, possibly even more than you can find on the shopping streets in Dongdaemun. (OK that might be an exaggeration – there’s like tons of quality caps going for S$6-S$10?!!? That street is magic – but I digress.) Then there’s the ones who came back from Hangzhou with a gold medal around their necks. Of the 5 from Jeonbuk, 3 were in the starting 11. The other 2 were on the bench. So it was still a quality lineup – and the difference in class was clear. When you go away from home, and you are playing against a stronger team, you need a lot of things to go your way – you need to get your tactics spot on, you need to be resolute in defence, you need to take your few chances if and when they come, and you absolutely cannot concede an early goal. We Conceded an Early Goal The atmosphere was rocking before kick-off. The Crew was small in numbers but we tried our best to make ourselves heard. The Mad Green Boys (Jeonbuk’s biggest fan group) were far, far louder, and it was truly impressive to watch and hear. In an away game, you need to shut them up. You need the players to do something on the field to test their resolve. Keep it goalless for 20min, 30min, 40min, half-time. Famously, Real Madrid fans sometimes boo their players if they are losing at half-time. The Mad Green Boys themselves, have also stayed silent at times to show their displeasure with the former coach Kim Sang Sik for the club’s patchy form early this season. But the last thing we wanted, was one of the first things that happened. Jun Amano cut inside from the right, and he zipped a low shot into the back of the net from outside the box. I’ve seen some blame Zharfan for the goal, but I am not sure he is to blame. It was a shot taken first-time, with minimal backlift, and it was slotted into the far corner, nestling in the side-netting. Sometimes you just have to applaud a quality strike and I think this was one of those occasions. Early goal achieved, Jeonbuk did not have to commit too many men forward, the fans had the impetus to keep going, and our difficult task got 100x harder. I am pretty sure this was not how the coaching staff and players envisioned the first half when they were in the dressing room. Anu and Lionel Slander Anu Reading Telegram chats in the past week, you’d think that Anu was one or more of the following, 35 years old, one of the worst players in the Sailors team, one of the worst midfielders in Singapore, and ultimately just a crap player. Am I defending the moment in the game where his reaction to a light push by a Jeonbuk player indirectly led to a goal? No I am not at all defending it. I think he should have played on and not asked for a freekick (more on this later). I think the contact appeared to me to be very soft, and he should perhaps have played on. But does that mean he is complete crap? Of course not. Let’s not forget that in the ACL, we get 5+1 foreign players quota, so Anu really has to fight for

[Post-Match Thoughts] A Different League (Jeonbuk 3 Sailors 0) Read More »

[Preview] Jeonbuk vs Sailors – An Impossible Task?

I am writing to you from Korea. LCS has put us up in a nice cosy hotel right in the heart of Jeonju, where tomorrow’s action will take place. I will admit first that this preview may not be as useful to you as some of the other preview articles put out in the past. The reason for this is that I was not able to ask any of the Korean football experts to comment on their team in a meaningful way. I don’t think anyone is under any illusions about the magnitude of the task that faces our Sailors tomorrow. There is a huge gulf between the standard in the K-League and that of the SPL. However, in the wise words of Singaporean singer Linying – “we did it before, and we’ll do it again”. We faced K-League side Daegu twice last year and came away with 3 points, impressively beating them 3-0, before losing narrowly in the torrential rain 2-1. Could we do it again? Let’s dive into the preview. The Mad Green Boys If the following paragraphs about the fans sounds very complimentary, please forgive me for being nice to our very hospitable hosts. It’s 1am here in Korea and they have taken us out and about for the past 6h, first to a charcoal-grilled chicken place, and then to a seafood place. Copious amounts of alcohol were also consumed at each place, making the writing of this article a little harder – but write it I must, so let me tell you why this is relevant. The results achieved against Daegu were fantastic, but I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that out of the 6 fixtures in this group, this is by far the hardest. Supporters can sometimes be the 12th man, and numerous studies have shown that referees tend to give better decisions to home teams due to the pressure and atmosphere created by the crowd. The biggest difference between beating Daegu last year and attempting to beat Jeonbuk this year is an actual home advantage enjoyed by Jeonbuk. This is incontrast to last year’s centralised tournament held in Buriram. Part of the advantage stems from the Mad Green Boys, who are permanently given the no. 12 in the squad, underlining their importance to the team. I watched on TV their game against Daegu – away from home, and they were LOUD. It is no wonder that they were voted by their fellow fans as the most intimidating set of supporters in the K-League in 2016. There’s something quite intimidating about a large bunch of people in green jumping up and down with wild abandon, and having witnessed first-hand their enthusiasm and vigour throughout this evening’s festivities, I can say for certain that the Crew is gonna be outshouted for sure tomorrow. While the numbers may not be as impressive as for weekend games, I expect a healthy number to still turn up and create a formidable wall of green. It will be intimidating. Jeonbuk’s Struggles This Season Tipped by many to be the winner, and automatically assumed by most to challenge, Jeonbuk have been disappointingly off the pace. Their attack in particular, seems to have suffered following the departure of former Swansea forward Modou Barrow. He notched 13 goals and 8 assists for Jeonbuk in his final season, from a mere 28 games. That is not easy to replace. His style of play also helped to create chances and relieve the pressure for his team because his supreme pace meant that teams dared not press as high up. You add to that the mid-season departure of Cho Gue-sung to the Danish league, and then it becomes even more telling why the attack has sputtered this season. If the name rings a bell, Cho was the Korean striker who scored 2 goals against Ghana at the World Cup in 2022, announcing himself to the world. Of course, they still have Gustavo, and other attacking threats. However, their scoring numbers fill me with 1% of hope that perhaps we can do well to shut them out. You be the judge – Remember that Cho Gue-Sung is no longer there, and Gustavo is not a striker who can create his own chances upfront too. However, given adequate service in the box, he is absolutely deadly, so we have to keep a close eye on him. It is fair to say that we are lucky they are not the force they were last year, or in the years prior, where they made mincemeat of Tampines Rovers. How will the Sailors line up? I think the squad pretty much picks itself. For me, the only doubt would be whether Shawal Anuar features after his superb cameo at the weekend. If you go with 5 at the back, that necessarily means you need 2 central midfielders and those will be Rui Pires and Anu. That leaves 3 spaces up top and it will not be surprising for LCS fans to see Diego Lopes, Lestienne and Zivkovic picked as the starters. Having watched Jeonbuk play, they like to press very high onto their opponents. Led by Boateng in the middle, they tend to want to snap into challenges in or around the penalty area. This of course leads to turnovers – something that we need to watch out for. However, it also gives us an escape route. Should we be able to evade the press somewhat, we can try to go long, and hope that there is enough space behind the backline for our forwards to deal with. This is where perhaps keeping Shawal on the bench may help. He very seldom lasts the whole game anyway, so it’s good to keep him in reserve, and then release the secret weapon against tiring legs in the second half. One thing I noticed while watching Jeonbuk this season is that they seem to have an inability to clear their lines properly when they defend their goal . I think

[Preview] Jeonbuk vs Sailors – An Impossible Task? Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Thug-jong Pagar Fall Apart After Red Card (Sailors 4 Tanjong Pagar 1)

It is not often that we can say a team that picked up 3 yellow card and 2 red cards were not punished adequately, but this is a view that I hope to be able to defend in this post-match thoughts article. While the Sailors picked up an expected win, and have one foot in the semi-finals, I think some of Tanjong Pagar’s conduct was very unsavoury, bordering on being thuggish. Especially in light of recent events involving referees, I hope that something can be done by FAS to warn all teams in the league against such conduct. Let’s dive right into it. Shakir is a Lucky, Lucky Boy Quite how Shakir Hamzah escaped a red card this game is beyond me. First Incident He should have received a yellow card as early as the 10th minute of the game. He slid in on Richairo Zivkovic and conceded a penalty after his trailing leg swept our star striker off his feet. While I can understand a player debating with the referee about whether the penalty call was legitimate, I don’t think we can excuse this. You be the judge. In my opinion, the aggression with which he runs to the referee, and then repeatedly encroaches on his space, forcing him to first backpedal, and then second, put out a hand, is worthy of a yellow card. I was quite surprised the referee didn’t give it. The hand out should have been the final warning. It effectively says to Shakir – back off, or you’re receiving a booking. Instead, Shakir repeatedly walks towards the back-pedalling referee, pushing his body into the protective hand of the referee. All this time, the verbal volleys don’t stop, even as his teammates try their best to stop him. Thuggish behaviour. Second Incident His anger didn’t stop here. A few minutes later, still seething at the penalty award earlier, Shakir kicks out at Maxime Lestienne even though Maxime was already dribbling away from goal after a quick throw from Izwan (more on this later). No intention to get the ball, he just swings a leg to the back of Maxime’s calf and catches him. Thuggish behaviour. A deserved yellow, nothing more. Third Incident In the 51st minute, Anu mistimes a tackle and seconds later, Hami commits a tactical foul on Shahrin Saberin who is breaking away at pace through the midfield. Both were challenges worthy of a yellow card, and the referee rightly gave yellows to both of them. However, once again, Shakir runs after the referee from a real distance away, and leads a pack of Jaguars to hound him. See the gif for yourself below. Look out for Shakir steaming in from the left. In fact, he comes in with so much pace he almost knocks the referee off-balance a little. The referee can also be seen to be wiping his face, so I suppose the shouting was so intense that he felt some saliva come onto his face. Again, thuggish behaviour. He is already on a yellow card at this point – so how does he escape a second yellow card for this? Surely the referee cannot be encouraging such behaviour. Just a week ago, Wan Tung Han, a senior referee was assaulted on the pitch after one of his decisions angered a player in an FA Cup match between East Coast United and GFA Victoria. That was in an amateur game. Now, let me make it clear, I am not condoning it just because the player who assaulted the referee was not a professional. I hope the police deals with him accordingly. But here’s some food for thought for us all – if our senior professionals are acting with such disrespect to the referees, then what kind of example are they setting for the rest of us weekend warriors who play in Sunday league games or amateurs in IWL? How about kids back home who think that this is acceptable? I hope the FA has a chat with clubs to ensure that there is no repeat of such scenes. After the chat, that’s fair warning, and if any player persists in such behaviour, they should be awarded a yellow card. A signal needs to be sent to try to stamp such behaviour out at all levels. Tanjong Pagar Should Change Their Animal Also, on a slightly light-hearted note, perhaps TPU should consider changing their animal. They are not jaguars, because … The screencap would suggest that they very much hunt in packs – it almost looks like the referee is handing out free Taylor Swift tickets or something. I repeat the points I made above about the example it sets for players all around Singapore. Tajeli Loses His Cool I’ve left the worst of the thuggishness for last. Tajeli completely loses his cool in the 88th minute, kicking out at Richairo, HARD, for absolutely no reason at all. Richairo had intercepted a loose touch from him, and there wasn’t any hint of a hard tackle or anything – it was 100% clean. I don’t quite know why Tajeli did it, but I can accept that a player sometimes loses his cool and does something inexplicable. I guess this is one of those occasions. He let his team down because they now lose him for the rest of the Cup. With Blake also suspended for their final group game, they have managed to turn a comfortable situation in the group into a real disaster. Richairo picked up a deserved yellow card for his retaliation, but I would say it takes a real saint to not be affected by a crazy challenge like this. I am glad he did not do more. Blake’s Yellow Cards His first yellow card was an interesting one. The commentator referred to it as a completely needless one, and characterised his action to push Izwan as one intended to antagonise the keeper. I don’t think it was that simple. Blake is usually a combative player but I believe

[Post-Match Thoughts] Thug-jong Pagar Fall Apart After Red Card (Sailors 4 Tanjong Pagar 1) Read More »

[Preview] Sailors v Tanjong Pagar – Delicate Balance Between Rotation and Securing Safe Passage

It’s been a while since we last saw our Sailors in action. More than 2 weeks ago, we managed to come away with a win in Hong Kong that reinvigorated our slim hopes of making it to the latter rounds of the AFC Champions League. While us supporters have had a chance to really kick back, relax, and bask in the warm glow of the away win, the players have not had such a luxury. Do we rotate and give us the best chance in Korea, or do we try our best to effectively sew up qualification in the Singapore Cup so the last game takes on less significance? 4 Games in 17 Days Of the 25 Lions called up to play the two matches against Guam, 10 were from the Sailors, and 9 featured. The only player who did not see any gametime was Zharfan. This has been a hectic time for these players. Let’s take a look at their schedule since the Kitchee game. 4 October – Kitchee v Sailors 12 October – Singapore v Guam 17 October – Guam v Singapore 21 October – Sailors v Tanjong Pagar Should our national team players feature again, it might be a case of 4 games in 17 days, along with 4 flights as well. That is a tiring schedule, especially taking into account he 13h journeys by air to and from Guam. The likes of Anu, Lionel, CvH, Mamat, Hariss, and Shawal saw significant gametime, and I do wonder if there is some temptation to give a rest to a few of them. However, given the injury and unavailability issues faced by the Sailors, it may not be feasible to rest all of them. One of the key figures that might dictate if people like Anu and Lionel may play is Bailey Wright. He has been out since early-September when he picked up an injury in a closed-door friendly against Albirex. Given that Anu, Lionel, and Hariss played many minutes against Guam and Kitchee, and Bailey hasn’t played at all, it would be ideal to let Bailey play – if he is fit. Is Bailey Fit? Plus Other Injury News Bailey Wright It’s really tough to say. Unlike Singapore’s favourite league, the English Premier League, injury news is very hard to come by as local clubs are often tight-lipped about player injuries and how serious they are. We are thus left to guess based on club training videos – a skill picked up through years of playing Fantasy Football (FF). For those unacquainted, FF is an online game where people pick players from various Premier League teams and sort them into a lineup of 11 players, and these said players then pick up virtual points based on their real-life performances in matches. FF is also a game taken way too seriously by people like myself, which thus results in crazy, irrational behaviour, such as looking for the littlest clues in training videos as to whether a player we picked is injured and will feature at the weekend. So, if you look at the training video below, scroll to around 2:30 and watch on for 10 seconds – you will see that Bailey Wright has resumed pitch training, and crucially, resumed pitch training in a group. However, of course, it must be said that that was a rondo/monkey training drill, which may not involve as much rigour as other drills which were not really shown. Nothing in the video shows Bailey doing anything that would really extend him as well, so it is hard to say if he will feature tomorrow. I guess we’ll see. If you don’t see Bailey, it’s cos his back is turned to the camera. Haha I am a psycho. Same applies for Pedro Henrique. While he cannot play tomorrow because he is not registered in our Singapore Cup squad, Coach Rankovic may be tempted to push one or two of Lionel/Anu/Hariss for the full 90 if he felt that Pedro Henrique was fit and ready to start against Jeonbuk on Wednesday. Kodai Tanaka This one’s not entirely relevant for tomorrow’s game but I just thought I’d comment on it. Kodai was injured on 9 March against Albirex. However, it was not until around the end of the month before he had his surgery. This can be seen from his post on 1 April, where he said he had his surgery two days prior. This is normal for ACL injuries – you cannot operate immediately. According to Dr. Andy Williams, an ACL reconstruction expert, you need to let the swelling go down and for the knee to go “quiet”, if not you risk adding to the trauma and in the long term, you may stiffen up the knee even more. So from 1 April till now, that’s about 6.5 months. You have seen from Kodai’s instagram posts that he has resumed training for quite a while already. While at first it was just solitary gym work, he has returned to the pitch to do solo training, and now he’s back in group training. As to the extent of how intense his training is, we can only guess from his posts and the training video above – but 6-9 mths is the usual timeframe. If you scroll to 4:31 – you will see that in a small-sided game, he comes sliding in to intercept a pass. To me, even though I am not an expert, I think this is a heartening sign. We definitely won’t see him against Tanjong Pagar, but maybe he’ll make it for the Jeonbuk game as a substitute? Let’s see if he travels with the team. It doesn’t seem like there’s any other injury news, so if Ranko is trying to more or less secure qualification tomorrow, this is perhaps a good chance to do it. Going for a Win to Secure Qualification A win will almost certainly put us into the semifinals. It is not mathematically confirmed of course, but let

[Preview] Sailors v Tanjong Pagar – Delicate Balance Between Rotation and Securing Safe Passage Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Hard-fought Away Victory (Kitchee 1 Sailors 2)

Sorry this one took so long. After the game, we had to go celebrate our team’s victory away from home, and also experience for ourselves the sights and sounds of Hong Kong. I took an extended holiday after that with my parents, and brought them around to see Hong Kong as well. Away days are special not just because of the football team that we follow, but also because it allows us to make friends with fellow football fans, and experience a different city. A win, is sweet, of course, don’t get me wrong. But I think the bonds forged on this trip would be no less strong even if we ended up losing this game. That being said, we never looked like losing this game. We may have almost chucked away a 2-goal lead to draw at the end, but thankfully we managed to survive that late scare to take home three vital points. Another reason for this one taking so long is because I had to rewatch the whole game twice. When you’re in the away stands behind the goal, it’s not the greatest view and your thoughts can be skewed by what you perceive from that angle. Clamping Down on Cleiton The Kitchee fans weren’t lying. Cleiton is a magnificent player. He turns 37 later this year and yet he moves around the pitch elegantly, efficiently, and quickly. He was involved in almost everything that Kitchee did as play flowed through him. Obviously, the Kitchee players also sought to look for him at every opportunity. But our Sailors clamped down on him, through fair or foul means. Whenever Cleiton got on the ball, one of Rui Pires, Diego Lopes, or Anu would be there, engaging him. Sometimes, even the rest of the players helped out. For example, Richairo loses the ball in the 15th minute, chases back a little, sees that it is Cleiton on the ball driving at speed, and gives him a little tug. Yellow card. Richairo does have a tendency to pull people back instead of running with them on defensive duty, but in this case, perhaps it is understandable. It is no surprise to see that Cleiton was the most-fouled player on the pitch. He was fouled 6 times. The next most-fouled player was Law Tsz Chun (more on him later), suffering 5 fouls. Of the 4 yellow cards dished out to Sailors players, 2 were for fouls on Cleiton. Maybe there was a tactical instruction to stop him from being so influential, or maybe he just had a knack for sniffing out space in midfield and thus the players knew that he had to be stopped, by hook or by crook. I think this was crucial in stopping Kitchee’s flow. Until Jantscher came on in the second half and tried to share the creative burden, I felt Kitchee was abit over-reliant on Cleiton being the sole source of inspiration. Law Tsz Chun – Steady on the Right I got many confused people tuning in to the broadcast and asking me why Kitchee was fielding a full foreigner lineup. The explanation is simple, quite a few of them are actually naturalised citizens because they have spent a long time in Hong Kong plying their football. A look at this recent Instagram post by Kitchee should make things clearer. They are all in the HK team. Law Tsz Chun is the only Chinese-sounding name in the lineup and for that he gets my utmost respect – it must be difficult being the only local-born person in the starting 11. This guy is someone to watch for the fans who are gonna head down to Jalan Besar for the return fixture in December. I was so impressed by him and his bags of energy down the right flank. Played at right wing in the first half, he became a right back in the second half when the coach made half-time changes. His directness caused problems for us, and as mentioned above, he was fouled 5 times. Always showing for the ball, and never scared to take on his man, I felt he was the most influential player after Cleiton for Kitchee that night. In fact, sometimes he was the one who helped Kitchee escape LCS’s press in the first half. He ended the night with an assist after his beautiful cross was headed in by Jantscher in the dying minutes of the game. but I felt his most important contribution was actually stopping LCS from making it 3-0. Just before half-time, with Kitchee in disarray, Richairo raced clear on the right wing, and it looked like 3-0 was inevitable because he had Diego Lopes running with him in support. But Law Tsz Chun not only kept pace, he managed to deflect the pass inside towards his keeper, and they avoided a damaging 3rd goal just before halftime. A fantastic performance from Law, and we will be watching him closely in the next game. Zharfan Answers His Doubters All season long, Zharfan has had his doubters. There were some moments where he could perhaps have done better, and sure, he’s no Hassan Sunny, but really, who is? I’ve always backed him this season, because Hassan aside, I don’t think there’s a better local keeper in Singapore. And Hassan has moved on, so who else would I get behind besides Zharfan? If you look at the saves alone, you might not think that Zharfan was overly extended against Kitchee. We’ve seen him make far more spectacular saves in the SPL – remember that double save against the Young Lions? However, I think his performance, taking into account his distribution and handling, were excellent. And in a must-win game where every mistake would prove costly? Just excellent. Interestingly, the lead-up to both goals sees Zharfan feature quite prominently. 2nd goal His contribution to our second goal is easy to notice – it was Zharfan’s quick thinking that saw him place a perfect drop-kick into the right channel

[Post-Match Thoughts] Hard-fought Away Victory (Kitchee 1 Sailors 2) Read More »

[Preview] Kitchee v Sailors – Perhaps No Better Time to Play Kitchee?

Abit of a late one – have been so busy clearing work to make time to fly over to Hong Kong to support the boys, and rather interestingly I got lost for an hour earlier in the meandering streets of Central, Hong Kong. But I am safe now, and in the next couple of hours before I head to dinner with some Kitchee fans, here is my preview of tomorrow night’s must-win game. Why, Eddy, you may ask, is this a good time to play Kitchee? Head Coach Sacked! Kim Dong-Jin Steps In Or rather moved aside to a “youth development” position – but we all know what that means. Alex Chu was sacked. Up steps Kim Dong-Jin as interim head coach. He is also the Technical Director of Kitchee. If you think his name sounds familiar, it may be because you watched him as a player playing for South Korea at the 2006 World Cup, or winning the Europa League with Zenit St. Petersburg. The reason for the sacking was touted as a move to “bring harmony to the club in pursuit of major trophies“. I mean that could mean a lot of things – but given that it came on the back of a poor performance in a 4-1 defeat to closest title challengers Lee Man, and a 2-1 defeat to Jeonbuk, could mean that there is some dressing room disharmony. Kitchee fans have also told us that not only was Alex Chu redeployed, several backroom staff also faced the same fate. It is not a happy camp at the moment, and I don’t need to look too far away for an example of how dressing room disharmony or dissatisfaction with management can lead to a team performing below par on the pitch – Sailors Singapore Cup campaign 2022, anyone? One thing though, will a Korean interim coach mean that Kim Shin-Wook, our old friend, returns to the starting line-up and plays a pivotal role? Korean Konnection Kim Shin-Wook was always a player who divided opinion amongst the fanbase. He had his supporters, fans who loved his goals and how he would oblige fans who mimicked his celebration (dropping to his knees and pointing to the sky), and yet other fans who felt that LCS’s starting striker given our resources should be much better, or at least more mobile. He did score 24 goals in 35 games though – I think opinion about him would have been a lot better if Boris Kopentovic did not have such a brilliant season last year. At the end of the day however, I think all fans would probably be united in agreeing that Richairo Zivkovic has been an upgrade. But how has our Wookie fared since he transferred to Kitchee? Not well, apparently. Go take a look at the highlights from my interview with Kitchee fans Edmund and Tim – pretty scathing. Last season, Wookie finished with the now-overused 007 meme, as he recorded 0 goals and 0 assists in 7 appearances. (I say overused but yet I still use, lol) This season, he has only seen gametime against much inferior opposition. He took to the pitch and scored a hattrick against semi-pro opposition, and just last weekend, he played in a 6-2 victory in the league, but when he was subbed on, he managed to miss a penalty, and also the rebound (which would not have counted anyway because it came off the crossbar). Apparently he approached the hardcore fans and apologised to them for his performance and looked tearful. It pains me to say this because I’ve always liked him, but it’s not going well for sure. I tell you why I like this guy though – I think it takes some balls and also shows that the player cares if he goes to the fans and talks to them, knowing full well that they don’t have full faith in him. Prior to this season, he also cut short his summer break so that he could train more in a bid to raise his performances. However, even if Kim Dong-Jin gives him a chance and starts him against us (unlikely), I still think Kitchee may not be the force they were last year when they qualified for the knockout stages because Wookie is no DEJAN DAMJANOVIĆ. Big Dejan-Sized Hole in the Attack Kitchee qualified for this year’s ACL by virtue of them finishing first in their domestic league. They also won the treble, and usually treble-winners are kinda invincible, no? Well, even though they had Dejan Damjanović with them at the tail-end of last season, it was interesting to watch in an interview with Hong Kong football expert Christie Leung that she felt Kitchee only just barely clung on to win it at the death, and the performance was not convincing. And that’s with Dejan in attack! Why all this fuss about Dejan, you may ask. Well, Dejan Damjanović is only the top ACL goalscorer of all time. He is also a K-League legend. I will let his numbers do the talking for me. The pitch graphic is for number of appearances, the blue-ball graphic is for goals, and the green ball graphic is for assists. Just an insane player – and you consider that what he did for Kitchee was after he had turned 39 years old? Just madness. And he turned in solid performances in the ACL campaign too, not just in the domestic league. Christie Leung also mentioned in the interview that Dejan’s absence is compounded by Kim Shin Wook’s failure to step into his massive boots. The Kitchee fans had hoped that following the same blueprint in bringing over a K-League legend in Kim, might have led to similar success, but it was not to be. Kitchee’s performances this season have not been useful for me to analyse because the gulf in quality between them and the other Hong Kong sides (with the exception of Lee Man, which they lost to) means that there

[Preview] Kitchee v Sailors – Perhaps No Better Time to Play Kitchee? Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Much Easier than Expected (Balestier Khalsa 0 Sailors 7)

There was a moment in the first half of this game, when Balestier scored a blatantly offside goal. It was so offside that the Balestier players didn’t even celebrate it, they just retreated back into position. Izwan also just turned around to retrieve the ball for a free kick. Noone thought it was a goal that would stand. Well, one person did. The person in charge of stadium music got a bit excited and pressed the big red button that said “TIGERS GOAL, GET INNNNNN – PLAY EYE OF THE TIGER“. The song came on for a bit, people realised something was wrong, and then it stopped. In many ways, that was the story of Balestier Khalsa on Monday night. They showed up for the game, but did they really show up? Not in my opinion. Only a handful of players really tried. Just like the song, it was half-hearted, and ultimately, killed very quickly. Let’s dive right into this, and other post-match thoughts. Balestier Khalsa Did Not Show Up Lack of fixtures They just didn’t show up. Could it be that they just haven’t had enough football in recent times, thus killing their momentum? They had a month-long break between 20 Aug and 15 Sep, when they played their last league game. Although there were two international fixtures during that time (like the rest of the world), I am not entirely sure why the break was so long. You compare that with earlier on in the season when Balestier were made to play 4 games in 11 days and you wonder what’s going on with the scheduling. When games are so spaced out, teams do lose momentum a little. The Sailors at least came into the game having played 2 games, once against Geylang in the final match of the season, and then a few days later against Bangkok United. Lack of desire For whatever reason, the Tigers seemed to lack any fight in them. I can remember only a few crunching tackles from Jordan and Madhu, some energetic running around from Ho Wai Loon, but even the usually combative and energetic Hoshino and Daniel Goh seemed to be very muted. The best example of this lack of desire came in the lead-up to the 5th goal. Ho Wai Loon’s disguised pass was read well by Anu, who deflected it into the path of Hafiz Nor. Hafiz Nor showed his mind is even quicker than his pace, immediately playing the ball to Diego Lopes in the centre of the pitch with a one-touch pass. Balestier were in trouble. Ahead of Diego is Shawal, who you can see in the picture above, and Richairo, who you cannot see. He’s with Madhu, slightly out of the shot. I picked this picture so you can see that there are 3 Balestier players who should start busting their gut to get back and help. Note the distances between the players. Look at Iqram’s distance with Shawal. This shows what Balestier is dealing with. It’s a 3v2 at the back – and the distances have widened. Ryoya is further from Diego now, Iqram is further from Shawal now. Iqram’s lack of desire to run back merely 14 minutes after coming on will be quite worrying for Balestier fans. Had he run back to defend, Jordan and Madhu would then be able to shift across and try to cover Diego and Richairo. As it was, this is your classic Attack v Defence drill where the coach puts fewer defenders than attackers to get the attackers used to finding the open man. This is textbook training ground stuff. Madhu tried his best – in fact in this moment above he managed to read and block an attempted pass by Diego on the inside to find Richairo. Had the other defenders come back in time, this might have killed the Sailors momentum or at least made it harder for Diego. Instead, he had the time to get the ball back from the deflection, and play it round the outside for Richairo to leave him 1v1 with the keeper. Funnily enough, even the referee is closer to the Sailors players than the retreating Balestier midfield. Where is Ryoya? The last picture is like those scenes at the end of an action movie, where a couple is being tormented by some psychotic serial killer. They call 911 for help, but the help never arrives. They find ways to keep themselves alive, they fight and struggle and get hit and fall down stairs and whatnot. They will never die of course, but at the end, after the psychotic serial killer is finally dead, the sirens will sound and the police will arrive – way too late. That is how you’d describe the Balestier midfield. Too little, too late by the time they appeared. In a match where Balestier looked very lackluster, I think this was the most glaring example. There is already a gulf in quality, and it was made worse by a lack of effort. I’d be fuming if I was a Balestier fan. Contrast this with an incident in the 30th minute of the game, with Sailors already 3-0 up, and Richairo lost the ball near the Balestier penalty area. He chased down his tackler and managed to win the ball back near the halfway line. For a man who was labelled as “lazy” when he made his debut for us, that was a very encouraging sign. Which brings us to the next topic … Richairo Needs to Get On the Ball More A hat-trick within the first 45 minutes. He is without doubt, one of the best players on the team. Not only is he strong and fast, he can shoot on either foot as well. He also shows a keen awareness of where his teammates are and is able to link up with them effectively. All these qualities were on display against Balestier. His first goal was an example of how difficult it is to

[Post-Match Thoughts] Much Easier than Expected (Balestier Khalsa 0 Sailors 7) Read More »

[Preview] Balestier Khalsa v Sailors (No Lestienne as Attention Turns to the Cup)

After midweek disappointment against Bangkok Utd, attention turns to the Singapore Cup. To me, it’s as important as the Champions League to the club, but for very different reasons. While the Champions League offers the club prestige on the continental stage, and the chance for fans to experience glamour ties, whether at home or abroad, the Singapore Cup is attractive because it offers us a realistic chance to win our first silverware in 2 years. That is not to say that I underestimate our local sides – but when you compare them to our chances in the Champions League, you can see where I am coming from. There is no room for complacency though. We’ve seen this season how “lesser” sides such as Young Lions and DPMM have caused us trouble. While tonight’s opponents have been beaten by us thrice this season (Played 3, Won 3. Scored 13, Conceded 6. (3-0, 5-4, 5-2)), they have not been easy games. The stand-out of course is the 5-4 game where we almost snatched defeat from the jaws of victory, but even the 5-2 game wasn’t as easy as it looked despite Balestier having a man sent off early. So yes, this will be a tough game, and it will be made slightly tougher because as you might have seen from the headline ….. Maxime Lestienne is Suspended At the back-end of last season, in the disastrous Singapore Cup campaign, Maxime picked up a yellow card in the 2nd group stage game against Young Lions, and another in the 3rd group stage game against Albirex. And Singapore Cup rules state that if you pick up 2 yellow cards, you miss the next game. And since we didn’t qualify for the semi-finals last year, Max serves his suspension tonight. Obviously this will be a big miss, as he is the league’s top creator and top scorer. I don’t really need to elaborate further. I still think a frontline containing Zivkovic and Shawal Anuar cannot be said to be poor, so we are still favourites. If anything, this will be a test for our Sailors to see if we are over-reliant on Max. I thought that against Bangkok United, Max wasn’t at his sparkling best and could not put the team on his back in the search for an equaliser. But in a team with so much talent, it is perhaps unfair for us to expect that to happen. So I think this might actually be a good opportunity for someone like Haiqal Pashia, who I believe might come into the thinking for Coach Ranko, especially with the absence of Abdul Rasaq as well for the rest of the season. Interestingly, he features heavily in the pre-match buildup article. If the rest of the team is solid, a frontline of Pashia, Richairo and Shawal should still send chills down the spine of defenders, given their fantastic mobility and the potential to interchange positions. Let’s not forget that while Balestier had a stellar season, finishing 4th, they conceded 71 goals, just 5 fewer than Young Lions, and in so doing, ended up with the 2nd-worst defence. Last point to note? During the international break there was a closed-door friendly played against Balestier Khalsa, and while they did not have their national team players, we also didn’t have Maxime Lestienne with us, and the team still managed to record a handsome victory. Maybe a sign of things to come? Lionel Tan is Not Suspended The title of this section should clear it up for you if you had any doubt. Lionel Tan is not suspended. The nonsense red card he received in our last league game carries over to the SPL only, not to the Singapore Cup. As such, he will be available. This is vital, considering we’re probably gonna be without Bailey Wright. Given that he wasn’t even fit enough for the bench in our crucial Champions League tie, I highly doubt he will be available to start against Balestier tonight. Who will partner Lionel at the back? Will it be two centre-backs? Or three? If we line up with three centre-backs, then we will know that the priority is well and truly on the Champions League as we try to build some familiarity with the formation. It is possible that Bill comes in at the back to partner Lionel. After all, with Nur Adam being enlisted, we will need a U23 player to come in and start the game. Of course, this rule might also be fulfilled by Harith Kanadi coming into the side. Or who knows? Maybe Nathan Mao will be given a start? Banishing the Ghosts of Yesteryear While we have beaten Balestier Khalsa thrice this year, I still forever remember the two collapses we had late in the season last year against them – one in the SPL, and one in the Cup. It is no exaggeration to say that Balestier Khalsa ended our hopes of silverware last year with the 5-3 loss in the league and the 3-3 draw in the cup. The circumstances are very different of course. Hassan Sunny has come out to say in a few interviews that the atmosphere was very bad at the club at that time, because people were not getting their contracts renewed, and he knew there was going to be an exodus of players. There was also all kinds of drama as Izwan was the preferred keeper in the Cup, and as Hassan stated in his interview with Raushan, he does not share the best relationship with Izwan. Whatever the reasons for last year’s collapses, this is a squad with fresh blood, and that is still competing on two fronts. I hope that there is not as much off-the-field drama this time and we can put our best foot forward and win this game. Which Keeper Starts? Izwan is back from injury, and some may say that since he was the cup goalkeeper last year, maybe he will be the cup goalkeeper

[Preview] Balestier Khalsa v Sailors (No Lestienne as Attention Turns to the Cup) Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] No Shame in Defeat, But a Huge Uphill Battle Now (Sailors 1 Bangkok Utd 2)

It was a dream start for us in our first ever home game in the AFC Champions League. Last season’s “home” games don’t count because they were all played in Buriram in a centralised tournament due to Covid-19. As is so often the case, whenever Chris van Huizen gets a cross into the box, things happen. Last night was no different. As the left-footed cross was whipped into the box, it was half-cleared to our Brazilian magnifico, Diego Lopes. He had sent a shot high and wide just 5 minutes ago, but this time, he hit it sweetly on the volley, and it nestled in the bottom corner of the net. Jalan Besar erupted. After a long period where we sat deep and frustrated our Thai guests, this was a much-needed boost of energy. We all know how this one ends, so there’s no need for a spoiler alert, but at the time, it was a sweet moment for the fans. It’s now a day later, so there’s been some time to process my thoughts about the game. Tactical stuff I will touch on, but not in detail – I will leave that to Zach as usual in our upcoming Tactical Analysis article. Let’s go. Angst about the Angst Post-match, after I went about doing all the interviews (both player and fans), I went online to look at the reactions to the Sailors’ defeat. While there were some comments commending the atmosphere, and others acknowledging the effort put in by the players, there were also annoyingly, rather many comments having a go at our players, saying that they lacked effort, were very poor, or were not well-prepared – often a combination of all the above. I felt that based on the eye-test and what I observed during the game, these comments were unfair and were perhaps borne out of angst at the final result. Not analysis, not rational thought, just angst. And then I ended up getting angsty too. I think for me what really swung it was that it was not only the faceless Internet trolls having a go – it was our fans in the SailorFanTalk Telegram chat. Comments such as “they aren’t well-prepared for the tournament during training“, “it feels like we suddenly cannot play football and play like YL“, “players have no desire “, “when we have the ball, how do we keep [the ball]? It’s got nothing to do with opponent“. Where was all this negativity coming from? And in the case of the last comment, how can someone be so angsty that logic flies out of the window? How can your success in keeping the ball not be at least in part affected by the quality of your opponents? These are unfair comments that unnecessarily shit on our own players, players we should be supporting. It was as if people had forgotten that the Sailors were the underdogs coming into this game. Maybe they should read this blog a bit more! Haha. [This way if you wanna re-read the preview.] Then there were people who asked a fair question – could we really count ourselves as underdogs? We were after all, a little lucky in the draw and had escaped drawing the likes of Urawa Red Diamonds and Kawasaki Frontale. Some people felt quite rightly, that we were in the “easiest” group. I think however, the reality is that in the ACL, almost any group we get drawn into, we are gonna be underdogs. Here was my response in full – And that brings me to my next point – in the cold light of day, having rewatched the game, and also with the benefit of statistical reports, can we say that Bangkok Utd didn’t really create any good chances? Our Sailors Did Well Defensively Against a team top of the Thai League, a team that finished 2nd in the league last year, and that had also beaten the reigning champions 2-0 this season, we did well. Really well. Considering the quality of our opponents, I think to limit them to under 1 xG, is very impressive. This was also borne out by the eye-test, where they hardly created any good opportunities. The best chance for our opponents I think was the second half opportunity for Mahmoud Eid which shaved the post on its way out – he was kept quiet all night by the impressive Mamat. As mentioned in my Telegram message earlier, the goals came from slightly bad marking at one set-piece (disappointing of course), and a piledriver right into the top corner. While the players are not blameless in this, I am not sure we should be faulting their effort. Here’s another interesting stat to show you which I think speaks to the effort the players put in – duels won. In terms of duels, we pretty much outperformed them in almost every category, which suggests desire was not the problem. In fact, one of the enduring memories for me from this game was the sight of Richairo Zivkovic running back on more than one occasion all the way to the line of our penalty area to help out in defence. Desire was definitely not the issue and defensively our Sailors frustrated our opponents. In the post-match press conference, Bangkok United manager Totchtawan Sripan said that in their pre-match analysis, they had prepared for the Sailors lining up with 5 at the back despite not doing so in the domestic league. It is to our Sailors’ credit that even though our opponents knew what was coming, they still struggled to create chances. But could we have been slightly more attacking? Let’s discuss that. Should Sailors Have Opened Up More? I can’t lie – this was a thought that kept nagging away at me after the game (and maybe even at times in the first half). While we limited our more illustrious opponents to nothing more than half-chances and long shots, we ourselves did not pose a consistent threat. Often, our

[Post-Match Thoughts] No Shame in Defeat, But a Huge Uphill Battle Now (Sailors 1 Bangkok Utd 2) Read More »