April 2025

[Preview] Sydney FC v Lion City Sailors (Biggest Game of the Season)

I feel like this season we’ve had a few high-pressure games already. I don’t have to rehash our journey and how we got here – maybe I’ll do that if we get to the final. But you know the games I am talking about. The thing about pressure is this – much like how a muscle that you train gets stronger and stronger, I think your brain starts getting used to pressure until it becomes the baseline. What used to be a high-pressure situation, is now just normal-pressure. What used to be normal-pressure, is now no-pressure. You get the drift. I think the players now are used to such high-pressure situations. And this is our biggest game of the season (so far). Holding a 2-0 lead and having to defend it in Sydney will not be easy. But in the wise words of Linying – we did it before, and we’ll do it again. Let’s jump right into the preview. The First Leg Result Could Have Been Very Different Our defence held very firm in the first leg, and Izwan only had 2 shots to deal with. However, you may remember that when Segecic came on, he had 2 shots that really, on another day, could have gone in. One whizzed past the post, while the other was denied by a great block from Bailey Wright. There are only so many things you can control on any given matchday, and while you can work on minimising chances, it’s sometimes hard to control whether your opponents are clinical. Sydney FC themselves may feel hard done by, because they limited us to 3 shots on target, and frankly the only one that was a good chance, was well-saved by their keeper. Bart Ramselaar’s goal is one for the ages, while Lennart Thy’s goal was also struck from a very improbable angle. On another day, Bart hits the bar, Lennart hits the post, and we’re looking at a very different equation. All that waffle isn’t to say that Sydney FC is definitely gonna beat us. Essentially all I did, was to tell you that football is a high-variance sport – the better team doesn’t always win. I am just saying that I am not getting carried away just yet, and I think tomorrow is gonna be a super tough game. Douglas Costa Fully Rested Sydney FC faced top-of-the-table Auckland FC at the weekend and drew 2-2 (with Segecic scoring both goals), but there were 2 notable absentees – Douglas Costa and Patryk Klimala. There are some murmurs that Klimala has an injury, but Douglas Costa being left out shows you that Sydney FC have really prioritised tomorrow night’s game. They took a huge risk in doing so – had they lost that game, the sides below them would have been able to catch them out. Klimala has 6 goals and 3 assists in the ACL2 and is one of the undoubted dangermen. Our defence gave him very little space in the first leg, but it won’t be as easy in the slightly wider pitch in Sydney. Also, I don’t like the word “niggle” in the tweet above. I want something a little more concrete. A niggle sounds like he stepped on a Lego brick and his toe is a little swollen for a couple of days. Would have been nice if it was something like more concrete, like “Patryk Klimala misses out with a bout of chicken pox” – now that would be great cos it would mean he definitely wouldn’t be playing. I expect this “niggle” was nothing more than Sydney FC resting him for what is a very important match. Douglas Costa was invisible at Jalan Besar. After the game, I made the joke to a few friends, that Sydney FC would have played better if Douglas Costa was on the pitch. Jokes aside, he is obviously still a world-class player, and we will need to be very wary of him. Park the Bus? Parking the bus sounds like the logical thing to do, when you are 2-0 up away from home, but it won’t be easy to do that. Sydney FC have shown their weaknesses at the back, but they are joint-2nd in the A-League when it comes to goals scored. If you defend a bit too deep, you invite the likes of Douglas Costa, Adrian Segecic, Patryk Klimala, and Joe Lolley to take shots from range. They are all adept at doing that, so if we do that, we risk getting caught out. Adrian Segecic scored from here at the weekend. And because that wasn’t challenging enough for him, 20 minutes later he scored from out here. Both times, the ball rocketed into the top corner. Park the bus at your own peril. I think the key to tomorrow’s game is of course to defend well, but we must also carry a threat up top. Our ACL2 campaign has seen us achieve some crazy results, but they’ve always featured goals. It’s not been a campaign where we ground out results from sitting deep and forcing 0-0 results. As much as I fear Klimala, Segecic, Costa, I think they will also fear Shawal, Lennart, Maxime, Bart and Song. These players have stepped up for us at different points in our campaign so far, and tomorrow we will look to them for inspiration again. Hopefully, Coach Ranko sets us up in a way that allows their attacking talents to shine as well. Conditions Our previous away trips to colder climates have seen us really struggle. Jeonbuk we lost 3-0, Sanfrecce Hiroshima we lost 6-1, and Zhejiang we lost 4-2. Of course, the quality of the teams is also a factor – it is not just the weather. However, you can’t help feel that perhaps there are two factors when it comes to colder weather. We will see Sydney’s physicality come through a bit more tomorrow night, but hey we have a 2-0 lead. Hopefully we have a solid plan to

[Preview] Sydney FC v Lion City Sailors (Biggest Game of the Season) Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Bore Draw But We Have Bigger Fish to Fry (Sailors 0 DPMM 0)

A 0-0 draw against DPMM is obviously 2 dropped points, but here’s 2 quick thoughts. 1) DPMM defended really well and fully deserved their point, and 2) no Sailors fan truly cares because of our comfortable lead in the league table, and also we have much bigger fish to fry on Wednesday. (What are the origins of “bigger fish to fry”? It’s such an odd phrase. So the person who came up with it was … a chef? Presumably someone who works in a seafood restaurant? It’s an odd one – why would that be the go-to phrase for suggesting that you have more important obligations?) But here’s some quick thoughts. DPMM Defended Superbly As expected, without Hakeme Yazid and Miguel Oliveira, DPMM brought almost no attacking threat. It didn’t matter though, as they clearly came for a draw, and the time-wasting started as early as the first half. No blame attached to them at all. It’s what I would want my team to do too, if we were shorn of our biggest attacking talents. It’s just being realistic and pragmatic. Naumovski is the master of time-wasting in the league, and he showed that again last night. However, what we didn’t do enough is to test him more. This was a result of a lack of creativity in the Sailors’ performance last night, but also because the DPMM defence and midfield kept their shape well and made it very hard for us to create clear-cut chances. Muminovic in particular, was a rock at the back, using his size and presence well to repel attack after attack. Maxime Shaking Off the Rust I think it was good that Maxime played the full 90min. We don’t know if he’s going to start on Wednesday, because he’s been out for quite a while and only just got his first minutes in the last game against Sydney FC. Hopefully these 90 minutes in his tank will help him shake off some rust. His crosses in this game were sometimes slightly over-hit or slightly under-hit. He also had a great chance in the second half when a sublime Rui Pires through pass found him behind the defence and with only Naumovski to beat. He had time to take the ball down, but he chose to go for a sidefoot volley. Even then, I think he will be disappointed that he made the shot so comfortable for the keeper. Let’s hope we’ll see a better performance from him on Wednesday! Bart the Conductor of Late In recent games, when Maxime has been out, there may have been some who held a bit of fear, that we might struggle to create. However, in his absence from the starting lineup, we have scored 17 goals in 4 games, and Bart has helped himself to 5 goals and an assist. Through this run of games, he has been the primary instigator in offence, and every attack seems to flow through him. It is thus no surprise that last night, without him on the pitch, the team struggled a little to find their flow. Another aspect of Bart’s recent run of form is that he seems to be running a lot more to cover spaces in midfield and defence as well. You’ll remember even in the 6-1 defeat to Sanfrecce Hiroshima that one of the goals we conceded actually saw him giving away the ball in our penalty area. He’s put in a lot of effort in the last few games – so perhaps it was wise to leave him out of the squad entirely. Conclusion Even with these dropped points, we stay 5 clear of BG Tampines, with a game in hand. With 5 games left for BG Tampines, the maximum number of points they can reach is 72. With our healthy goal difference, realistically we only need 10 points from 6 games.You have to think that we will be able to get that over the line. It is all-or-nothing on Wednesday, so I can understand why our team looked a little reluctant to go all-in last night. Hopefully we see a much better performance in 4 days’ time. COME ON YOU BOYS IN BLUE! Written by Eddy Hirono Picture credit – Lion City Sailors If you’d like to support the work we do here at SailorFanTalk, you may want to visit https://ko-fi.com/sailorfantalk and leave us a tip!

[Post-Match Thoughts] Bore Draw But We Have Bigger Fish to Fry (Sailors 0 DPMM 0) Read More »

[Preview] Lion City Sailors v Brunei DPMM (Rotation No Obstacle for the Sailors)

First – in case you’re wondering, nope, I did not forget to write a post-match thoughts article to recap Wednesday night’s fantastic game and atmosphere. Given the rushed schedule I faced over the last few days – preparing for a new episode of the Kicking & Screaming podcast, editing the videos for upload on SailorFanTalk’s social media pages, and of course my full-time day job), a hurriedly-prepared article wouldn’t do justice to such a momentous night. The intention is to come back years later and read these post-match thoughts articles to really soak it all in once again. All the emotions, all the feelings, all the thoughts. And so that brings us to a first on SFT, where the preview of the next game is published before the post-match thoughts article for the prior game. The title says it all really, we should rotate, but it should still prove to be no obstacle for us to record three points at home, and push us that bit closer to our SPL title. Let’s go. No Miguel Oliveira Miguel Oliveira is DPMM’s Maxime Lestienne. He’s got 9 goals and 5 assists this season. That’s 14 goal contributions, and DPMM have only scored 37 goals. And he is suspended, wheee! We’ve put together a little table above that isn’t meant to be exhaustive. I’ve just taken some of the big-hitters from other clubs and plonked their names in there so you get a little context. Basically, this is a huge loss for DPMM, especially because they are already so goal-shy, and Hakeme Yazid looks unlikely to play in this game as well due to his rumoured suspension. Since that ill-fated trip to Russia, Hakeme has only featured once. It seems he isn’t allowed to travel out of Brunei, and since most of their games are away from home because their stadium is apparently allergic to football, he hasn’t been playing much as well. Davis Ikaunieks has 7 goals from 11 games (league and cup), and seems to have overcome a slightly slow start to life in Brunei. However, without Miguel Oliveira on the pitch, I fancy our defenders to be able to deal with anything they throw at us. Also, credit to the SPL for their timely preview article, from which I gathered that Miguel Oliveira would be suspended for tomorrow’s game. We may still not have a topscorers list or any other stats, but this is a good start. Please put up a yellow and red cards table too next season so fans and content creators can keep up to date! Rotation Ahead of the Sydney FC Game in Midweek As supporters, we want to rest everyone who played against Sydney in midweek. We know that we can afford to lose this game, we know that we really don’t want to see anyone come off injured. However, time and again, we’ve seen that generally isn’t what Coach Ranko likes to do, except when it was against Tampines Rovers earlier this season. We had just been pumped 5-0 by Cong An Ha Noi, and were going up against the other team to pump us 5-0 this season, BG Tampines Rovers. Sure, the gap between both games was only 3 days, but surely no one expected this amount of rotation – Of course, seeing how Coach Ranko rotates the team now, I think it’s more likely that this lineup was to punish those who played so poorly in Vietnam, or at least send a message to them. Coach Ranko may also look ahead to beyond the Sydney game to realise that we have another 6 days after to rest and recharge before we face DPMM again. Coach Ranko may also think about how good our Sailors looked on Wednesday, and how much of it was due to the commanding nature of the 8-0 win in the league prior to that. I can’t quite say what Coach Ranko will do, but given the form of Lennart Thy, Bart Ramselaar, and our defence, I’d be tempted to keep them off the pitch to ensure they are fit for the upcoming game. Sydney FC Have a Big Game of Their Own While we take on DPMM, Sydney FC also have a game this weekend, and it’s a big one. Auckland FC are their opponents who are top of the pile looking comfortable. Sydney FC are in the top 6 spots, which are crucial, because only the top 6 teams in the A-League regular season go on to play the finals series. For that to happen, Sydney FC must fend off the challenge of Adelaide United and Macarthur FC (former home of Sailors legend Valere Germain). Sydney FC absolutely cannot afford to rest players for this game, so that’s advantage for us ahead of Wednesday. Let’s hope for a 2-1 loss right at the death, with both Auckland goals coming in the 90+ minutes, and in the fury that ensues after, 12 players end up getting involved in a fight that results in minor injuries, just major enough to stop them from playing on Wednesday. Conclusion It’s likely to be another slightly low-key affair tomorrow night at Bishan Stadium, but of course, what could possibly compare to the emotions and highs of Wednesday? Let’s hope we see some fresh legs come in to help us keep our lead at the top comfortable. COME ON YOU BOYS IN BLUE! My predicted line-up Izwan Mahbud Akram Azman, Lionel Tan, Bailey Wright, Toni Datkovic, Sergio Carmona Hami Syahin, Song Ui-Young Shawal Anuar, Abdul Rasaq, Maxime Lestienne Score Prediction Joseph and I predict the scores and track our success in a table. Stay tuned to find out who is the prediction king! Eddy’s prediction: Sailors 4 DPMM 0 Joseph’s prediction: Sailors 4 DPMM 1 Written by Eddy Hirono  Picture credit – Lion City Sailors If you’d like to support the work we do here at SailorFanTalk, you may want to visit https://ko-fi.com/sailorfantalk and leave us a tip!

[Preview] Lion City Sailors v Brunei DPMM (Rotation No Obstacle for the Sailors) Read More »

[Preview] Lion City Sailors v Sydney FC (First Leg Di Sini, Second Leg Di Sydney)

Ok – the title wasn’t just because I had to let out a Dad joke that’s been brewing in my mind for a couple of days. I think a legitimate point can be made about the order in which you play your home and away legs having a great impact on strategy. When you play your first leg away in the absence of the away goals rule, it really suits the Sailors’ game. We can afford to be a bit more conservative, and wait for our opponents to make the first move. I think many of us would describe the Sailors as a team that thrives on transitions, and so if we had the first leg in Sydney, we could have perhaps taken advantage of space left on the counter-attack. We could also just try to remain solid throughout, knowing that if we survive with a draw in the away leg, we have a good chance of getting the goals at Jalan Besar. It’s a huge game in the club’s history, and I can’t wait for it to get started. But first, as is customary, the lowdown from Joseph Chin. The Lowdown on Sydney FC (By Joseph Chin) Origin The Sky Blues were founded in 2004 as part of an ambitious project by the Australian football authorities to introduce a unified professional football league. Previously, it was a mixture of several semi-professional state-level competitions. They are 5-time league winners and had also won the 2005 Oceanian Champions League (before Australian clubs came under the banner of AFC). Uniquely, this means they are actually the only city in the world to achieve two continental titles from DIFFERENT continents – Sydney’s 2005 OCL win, plus Western Sydney Wanderer’s 2014 win in the ACL. Sydney FC will hope to go all the way, which will then make Sydney the only city to have won both the ACL and ACL2 trophies. Legends Dwight Yorke – their first ever marquee signing. The former Manchester United striker of the noughties made waves as a huge signing for the A-League at the time, and scored 7 goals in 22 appearances, including being named the Player of the Match in the A-League Grand Final. Alessandro del Piero – World Cup winner and Juventus legend who made his mark in Sydney FC history as well. 24 goals in 48 appearances endeared him to the fans and meant that even though he became the A-League’s highest-paid player in history when he made his move from Juve at the grand old age of 38, he was seen as having a positive impact on the A-League. Bernie Ibini – A cult hero for both Sydney teams, unfortunately it never quite happened with us, as he left us with zero goals after 8 appearances. Signed as a mid-season emergency replacement after Kodai Tanaka was injured against Albirex, Bernie’s failure to get goals instead paved the way for Abdul Rasaq’s breakthrough season. The Man in the Hot Seat Ufuk Talay is one of only two former Sydney FC players to have been both player and manager. The native Sydneysider of Turkish descent enjoyed a decent playing career, both in his adopted and ancestral homelands before returning home to great success at Sydney. As part of the pioneer batch of players in the A-League, the former Galatasaray midfielder’s experience in key moments of their history (winning the 05/06 Grand Final and debuting in the 2007 Champions League) will be crucial for their chances as they seek to write new chapters in their history in their 20th anniversary year. Of course, we will also be hoping to help them write a negative chapter in their history tonight. Ones to Watch The Big Boss – Douglas Costa: Probably the biggest name player to pitch up in the Eastern side of the ACL2 draw. Having won 3 Bundesliga and 3 Serie A titles, as well as the Club World Cup, the tricky winger is one to watch in his globetrotting career that also included stops in Brazil (Gremio and Fluminense) and LA Galaxy. Captain – Rhyan Grant: Runaway record appearance holder for Sydney FC, cementing his legendary status and captaincy with his 311 appearances for his sole senior club after graduating from the prestigious Australian Institute of Sport in 2008 (kinda like our Sports School). Not related to the other Grant in defence, Alex Grant. Hotshot – Patryk Klimala: The Legia Warsaw youth product has had quite a journeyman career spanning 3 continents at the age of 26. A decent young striker with Celtic and NY Red Bulls in the pandemic years, the Polish age-group international has finally found his best form in Australia. In the ACL2, he has 6 goals so far, 1 behind our very own Shawal Anuar (or 2 if you count his goal against Sanfrecce Hiroshima). Man Between the Posts – Harrison Devenish-Meares: Remarkably, he dislodged long-time stalwart and Australian international goalkeeper Andrew Redmayne from the starting XI this season. All the more impressive when you consider that he has taken an unconventional route to professional football, featuring in US college soccer, and a youth stint at Romanian club Rapid Bucharest. Sydney FC is his hometown club and he sometimes defends the goal like his life depends on it. English Leagues – Joe Lolley: Joe briefly featured for Huddersfield Town when they were up in the Premier League but will be known more in England for his long stint with Nottingham Forest when they were a Championship club. He scored 24 times for them in 159 appearances. This season he has 9 goals and 7 assists in 20 A-League matches. He will be one to keep an eye on. Young and Dangerous – Adrian Segecic: Segecic is the crown jewel of the Sydney youth talent pipeline. The Australia youth international has used his sole season in the Netherlands (with 2nd division Dordrecht) to hone his attacking instincts on the wings, prior to his breakthrough season this year. 10 goals and 2 assists in

[Preview] Lion City Sailors v Sydney FC (First Leg Di Sini, Second Leg Di Sydney) Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Costa and Thy the Destruction Duo (Young Lions 0 Lion City Sailors 8)

Coach Ranko would have been forgiven for wanting to rest all his stars for this game against the Young Lions, but the Young Lions had no such luck, as he fielded a strong team that really put them to the sword after an early red card at 3-0. Some quick thoughts on the game. Lennart Thy Finally Settling In After my strong words last year when we signed Lennart Thy, I am glad that he has come good. In the article highlighting his signing, I called him a quali-thy addition, and said that anyone who thinks he is gonna be a Jermaine Pennant type of signing should seriously consider donating organs. Here it is – And this – I don’t have to repeat myself too much here, but his goal tally so far has really shown off his array of finishes. In the league, he has 27 goals, and this is how they’ve come so far. We asked him about this post-match, and his reply was a typically understated efficient German reply. He said rather matter-of-factly that as a striker, the ball can come to you in the box from any angle, any position, off deflections etc, so you just have to use any part of your body to score. He was being modest of course. Take his finish for his third goal of the night – That’s not an easy finish at all on your weaker foot. It may look easy, but I suspect in this league it’s only an easy finish for Tomoyuki Doi and Lennart Thy. The touch to set himself up, and then the calmness to drive it low into the bottom corner. Strikers sometimes are rated on their ability to create chances by themselves, while sometimes they are rated on their ability to make something of half-chances. Lennart Thy is very much in the category of the latter. Interestingly, in our post-match interview with him, he said that part of the reason for his improved form in the second half of the season is also because in the first half of the season, he tried to be very involved in build-up play, but he has now realised that the team needs him more to remain as the focal point of the attack. He now has an amazing 22 goals from 16 games in all competitions in 2025, and if we are to have a successful end to this season, we will hope that this form continues, especially on the continental stage where chances are harder to come by. Diogo Costa – Running Down the Wing You know how the Crew’s chant for Hafiz Nor goes. “Viva Hafiz Nor x2, Running down the wing, Hear the Sailors Sing, Viva Hafiz Nor”. With Hafiz Nor getting less and less gametime as the season progresses, we might have to find some way to lyrically fit Diogo Costa into this chant, despite the different number of syllables. He was relentless on the left wing, running down time and again to terrorise the Young Lions defence. Lennart Thy may have ended the game with 5 goals, but Diogo Costa ended the game with a very impressive 3 assists. This takes his season’s tally to 4 assists from 10 games, and interestingly, his only assist prior to this game was for Lennart Thy as well. When we signed him, little was known about him, but he’s really making people sit up and take notice. And all this within just 10 appearances! He has really strengthened the Sailors and credit has to go the backroom staff for unearthing this hidden gem. On Wednesday, he’ll probably not have as many opportunities to bomb forward, but let’s hope when he gets the chance to do so, he can continue putting in dangerous crosses like he always does. Song Available Again This part is only slightly related to the Young Lions game, but I thought I’d use this article to address the situation surrounding Song’s sending-off against BG Pathum in the Singapore Cup. We know what Song is capable of, we know what he adds to the team. He tends to be a scorer of great goals, rather than a great goalscorer, and his goal against Young Lions was a stupendous one. It was bent perfectly into the top corner from outside the box, and Aizil Yazid had no chance. I don’t think any keeper saves that shot by the way – it was that good. So it’s a relief that in such a packed fixture schedule, we have Song back because of this announcement from the FA. I am glad that in the end, common sense prevailed, and the right decision was taken. I think we can count our lucky stars that the result last game didn’t affect us too badly, as a draw would still have qualified us top of the group, but I really hope that the referees department does the right reviews of their training processes to ensure such a horrible error doesn’t happen again. Some fans wanted to see more action taken on the officials involved, but I think I am glad that at least, we got an acknowledgment and an explanation of the error, so teams know what is considered acceptable and unacceptable tackling in future. Also, I choose to focus on the fact that we have Song back – that might end up being crucial for us. Conclusion Overall, a fuss-free win. No shots from Young Lions at all underlines the dominance we had. When Maxime got injured, there may have been some worries that the team might suffer a little from a lack of creativity. I think those fears have since been proven to be completely unfounded, as our team has managed to continue scoring goals. Bart Ramselaar, in particular, has really turned it on in Maxime’s absence. Not much else to say about this game, so I’ll see you in the preview of the Sydney game! Oh and do check out a Spotify playlist I

[Post-Match Thoughts] Costa and Thy the Destruction Duo (Young Lions 0 Lion City Sailors 8) Read More »

[Preview] Young Lions v Lion City Sailors (Don’t Underestimate Young Lions)

On paper, this is a no-brainer – comfortable Lion City Sailors win. It’s top v second-bottom team in the league. What could go wrong? Let’s dive right into some quick thoughts on why Young Lions shouldn’t be underestimated, and also why we might not have it all our way tonight. Young Lions Picking Up Form While YL’s position looks bad, a closer inspection of the table shows that they are actually right on the tail of DPMM and Hougang United, especially if you take into account their game in hand. Impressively, even after losing top-scorer Itsuki Enomoto to BG Tampines in the transfer window, they seem to have picked up some positive results in 2025. Many people, myself included, predicted that they would fall away, but the stats paint a different picture. The stats would suggest that the team has more than made up for Enomoto’s absence, with the goals coming from other sources. They have also posted impressive results in the Singapore Cup, such as a 3-0 win over Hougang United, and a 7-1 hammering of Albirex Niigata (S). In the end. they narrowly missed out on qualification for the knockout stages. They are no pushovers now. Mindset Heading into the Game This is something I’ve talked about at length before. It’s been a very long season, and when we talk about the daily grind, I think the grind for the players is grindier than it’s ever been. Especially with a huge tie against Sydney FC on the horizon, I don’t think we can blame the players for feeling like these league games are a bit of a hindrance – something to get it over and done with as soon as possible. Will the players go in a little less hard, fearing that any sort of injury now is potentially a season-ending one? Will they want to exert less energy, saving themselves for the game against Sydney on Wednesday? Will Coach Ranko rotate with Wednesday in mind? So many variables, and of course, no real way of finding out. While we have a comfortable lead in the league, BG Tampines has been plugging away and the gap is now down to 4 points (though we have 2 games in hand). There is room to drop points, but losing would perhaps give BG Tampines some hope that they can claw their way back into the title race. The Return of Bill Mamadou Bill Mamadou went out to Young Lions in February to get more game time, and that’s a move that can only be beneficial for him. His development was stalling in the Sailors where he found minutes hard to come by. Since he’s joined the Young Lions, he has looked confident, and will be pumped up to deliver against his parent club today, to prove any doubters wrong. Let’s hope he doesn’t cause too much trouble for our forwards! Maxime Lestienne It’s not that we need Max for this game, but fans have been eager to know if he is going to be available for the Sydney game. Well, I don’t have any insider info on this, but I am guessing not based on his Instastories – Not sure if any dog in Singapore would need to wear such thick clothing. This suggests he could be back home in Belgium, recuperating from his injury. It looked like a dislocated elbow, and healing times for those can range from a few weeks to a couple of months. I don’t think we will see him on the pitch or even on the bench tonight, but fingers crossed he’s back for the Sydney game in some capacity. Conclusion Short preview for a game where everyone on and off the pitch will be thinking ahead to the Sydney FC game. Hopefully it’s not too much of a distraction that our players end up dropping points. COME ON YOU BOYS IN BLUE! My predicted line-up Izwan Mahbud Chris van Huizen, Lionel Tan, Bailey Wright, Toni Datkovic, Diogo Costa Hami Syahin, Song Ui-Young Obren Kljajic, Lennart Thy, Bart Ramselaar Score Prediction Joseph and I predict the scores and track our success in a table. Stay tuned to find out who is the prediction king! Eddy’s prediction: Young Lions 0 Sailors 2 Joseph’s prediction: Young Lions 0 Sailors 5 Written by Eddy Hirono If you’d like to support the work we do here at SailorFanTalk, you may want to visit https://ko-fi.com/sailorfantalk and leave us a tip!

[Preview] Young Lions v Lion City Sailors (Don’t Underestimate Young Lions) Read More »

[Post-Match Thoughts] Grave Refereeing Error Sours Qualification (BG Pathum 1 Sailors 1)

You can’t write anything about this game without discussing the hugely controversial decision in the first few minutes of the game. Song Ui-Young goes in to close down Kodai Tanaka at the touchline and puts in a late tackle that grazes the knee of the BG Pathum player. Kodai goes down, and bounces up almost immediately, and the foul is given. Jansen Foo brandishes the yellow card. They give each other a pat, and then go back to take up their respective positions for a freekick. It is important to note that at this point, no one on Earth, Jansen Foo included, felt that it was worthy of a red card. While Jansen Foo took most of the heat, it was actually Andrea Verolino who made the bizarre call to send him to the screen. We don’t know what was said, but the fact that this was even considered a red card-worthy incident is baffling — something only a non-footballing mind would entertain. I will elaborate on why I feel so in this piece, so let’s dive right in. Singapore’s Very Own Myles Lewis-Skelley Incident Fans of Arsenal or the English Premier League will likely remember this one. Earlier this season, Arsenal made the trip to Wolves, and Michael Oliver gave a red card to Arsenal player Myles Lewis-Skelly (MLS). It was a similarly baffling incident, where everyone in the world except the referee felt it was a red card. Michael Oliver gave the red card for serious foul play, which is presumably what Jansen and the VAR team thought of Song’s tackle as well. The similarity lies in that both tackles contacted areas of the leg which are usually considered bad tackles. In MLS’s case, it was above the ankle, while for Song’s case, it was on the knee. Also in both cases, the contact was minimal and definitely unintentional. It was part of a natural motion to make an admittedly illegal challenge. For MLS, he went in to trip the advancing Wolves player, so the intended action was a tripping action by just sticking out the foot to let the player fall. In Song’s case, he’s gone in to try to intercept the pass but was late. His momentum takes his whole body into Kodai, but the majority of the contact is an excessive body impact on the upper body of Kodai, not the incidental studs near the knee. You have to really slow the replay down to even see any contact with the knee. In the aftermath of the MLS incident against Wolves, there was widespread condemnation of the horrendous decision from pundits and experts all over the world. In the end, Howard Webb, the referees’ chief, was forced to come out and admit that it was an error, and Michael Oliver should have given a yellow card instead. What is important to note is the reason for it. In Webb’s own words – “The referee sees a raised foot make high contact and the opponent went down … But we know that for serious foul play, we need excessive force or brutality and what we see here is that high contact [just] glancing and coming off the leg quite quickly … So for that reason, everybody pretty much in the game has formed the same conclusion that this is falling short of serious foul play – because of that glancing contact … because the studs don’t really go right into the leg, they glance in…” Man – that word for word describes what Song did. And the worst part about this is, you don’t even need a referees’ chief to tell you this. That’s why there was so much anger against Michael Oliver, and so much anger against Jansen Foo at the weekend. Anyone who’s played football knows that minimal contact outside the foot doesn’t automatically warrant a red. If it did, we’d see sendings-off every week. Context and intent matter, and neither suggested a red here. For a referee and a VAR team not to apply common sense and view the tackle in its proper context, is very disappointing. Kodai’s reaction to the tackle is very telling, by the way. He goes down, but immediately shrugs it off and exchanges pats with Song. No one on the BG team is baying for a red card. Everyone knows – this isn’t a red card. Well, everyone except Jansen, and the VAR. Accountability When players make mistakes, they get dropped from the team. When coaches make mistakes, they get sacked. When SPL referees make mistakes, there is seldom an explanation given, and the referee continues refereeing instead of being demoted to SFL or a lower level. There is a sense that the referees are untouchable. The abuse Jansen received from the stands, and online, wasn’t the result of one bad performance, however bad it was. It was the accumulation of frustration from years of bad performances. See my article on this from 2023. Even if the referees department feels that they didn’t make a mistake in this situation, there needs to be an explanation so that all parties can learn from it. Players and coaches need to know what is acceptable and unacceptable conduct so that they can play or plan accordingly. However, there is unlikely to be one. The PGMOL in England has their flaws as well, but what I like about them is that the audio between the VAR and the referee is released. I think it helps to build trust in our referees, and has the added benefit of allowing the fans to learn more about what is currently a very opaque process. At the end of the day, this mistake by Jansen and the VAR team didn’t affect our Sailors because we still qualified top of the group, and I suspect because of that, the refereeing department won’t see a need to address this, but they really, really should, for the good of our game. Does Song Need to Tone it Down?

[Post-Match Thoughts] Grave Refereeing Error Sours Qualification (BG Pathum 1 Sailors 1) Read More »